Think Tanks
Here's a look at documents from think tanks
Think Tanks
Featured Stories
Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves
MUNICH, Germany, Nov. 20 [Category: ThinkTank] -- ifo Institute posted the following news release:
* * *
Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves
*
* Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves
The business climate for the mechanical engineering sector in Germany has continued to improve, rising to 7.6 points, up from 4.1 points in September. For the first time since the winter of 2023, companies were positive about their current business situation, with a score of 1.5 points. Their business expectations rose significantly to 14.0 points, up from 10.7 ... Show Full Article MUNICH, Germany, Nov. 20 [Category: ThinkTank] -- ifo Institute posted the following news release: * * * Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves * * Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves The business climate for the mechanical engineering sector in Germany has continued to improve, rising to 7.6 points, up from 4.1 points in September. For the first time since the winter of 2023, companies were positive about their current business situation, with a score of 1.5 points. Their business expectations rose significantly to 14.0 points, up from 10.7points in September. "The overall economic recovery and increased demand are providing a boost to the mechanical engineering sector," says ifo industry expert Nicolas Bunde.
Additional orders are coming in, driven primarily by the global expansion of AI infrastructure and rising defense spending. The mechanical engineering sector is benefiting from that, among other things, as a supplier of production technology, components, and sensor technology. According to the survey, their order books filled up for the fourth month in a row, and they increased production compared with September.
Employment expectations, however, remained in negative territory at -7.2 points, up from -7.3 points in September. "Despite the improved sentiment, companies remain cautious when it comes to personnel planning," says Bunde. "Geopolitical tensions and international competitive pressure continue to weigh on the export-oriented mechanical engineering sector."
***
Original text here: https://www.ifo.de/en/press-release/2026-11-20/climate-mechanical-engineering-sector-germany-improves
* * *
Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves
*
* Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves
The business climate for the mechanical engineering sector in Germany has continued to improve, rising to 7.6 points, up from 4.1 points in September. For the first time since the winter of 2023, companies were positive about their current business situation, with a score of 1.5 points. Their business expectations rose significantly to 14.0 points, up from 10.7 ... Show Full Article MUNICH, Germany, Nov. 20 [Category: ThinkTank] -- ifo Institute posted the following news release: * * * Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves * * Climate for Mechanical Engineering Sector in Germany Improves The business climate for the mechanical engineering sector in Germany has continued to improve, rising to 7.6 points, up from 4.1 points in September. For the first time since the winter of 2023, companies were positive about their current business situation, with a score of 1.5 points. Their business expectations rose significantly to 14.0 points, up from 10.7points in September. "The overall economic recovery and increased demand are providing a boost to the mechanical engineering sector," says ifo industry expert Nicolas Bunde.
Additional orders are coming in, driven primarily by the global expansion of AI infrastructure and rising defense spending. The mechanical engineering sector is benefiting from that, among other things, as a supplier of production technology, components, and sensor technology. According to the survey, their order books filled up for the fourth month in a row, and they increased production compared with September.
Employment expectations, however, remained in negative territory at -7.2 points, up from -7.3 points in September. "Despite the improved sentiment, companies remain cautious when it comes to personnel planning," says Bunde. "Geopolitical tensions and international competitive pressure continue to weigh on the export-oriented mechanical engineering sector."
***
Original text here: https://www.ifo.de/en/press-release/2026-11-20/climate-mechanical-engineering-sector-germany-improves
Protecting Ratepayers, Conserving Water, and Boosting Revenue: New PPI Toolkit Shows Local Governments How to Make Data Centers Pay Off for Residents
WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 [Category: ThinkTank] -- The Progressive Policy Institute posted the following news release:
* * *
Protecting Ratepayers, Conserving Water, and Boosting Revenue: New PPI Toolkit Shows Local Governments How to Make Data Centers Pay Off for Residents
*
Communities weighing whether to host data center developments can use a set of practical tools to protect residents on electricity bills, water use, and noise while boosting tax revenue, according to a new report from the Progressive Policy Institute (PPI).
Authored by Andrew Fung, Senior Economic and Technology Policy Analyst ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 [Category: ThinkTank] -- The Progressive Policy Institute posted the following news release: * * * Protecting Ratepayers, Conserving Water, and Boosting Revenue: New PPI Toolkit Shows Local Governments How to Make Data Centers Pay Off for Residents * Communities weighing whether to host data center developments can use a set of practical tools to protect residents on electricity bills, water use, and noise while boosting tax revenue, according to a new report from the Progressive Policy Institute (PPI). Authored by Andrew Fung, Senior Economic and Technology Policy Analystat PPI, and Maximillian Levin, Public Policy Fellow at PPI, "A Data Center Toolkit for Local Government" lays out four goals local leaders can pursue when negotiating with developers: increasing tax revenue, controlling electricity prices, conserving water, and limiting siting impacts while boosting community benefits. It concludes that localities that publish their terms in advance and approve projects that meet them on a fixed timeline can capture the benefits of the data center boom on their own terms, positioning themselves well to get a good deal.
Public concern about data centers is growing. Polling from Embold Research found that 70% of registered voters oppose building a data center in their area, up from 52% in December 2025, and in the 2026 midterms, voters in dozens of communities approved local measures banning or restricting the facilities. Between 30% and 50% of U.S. data center projects slated for 2026 are expected to be delayed or canceled, leaving $130 billion in capital spending on hold.
But for communities that choose to host facilities, the fiscal upside can be significant, the report argues. Data centers generate substantial property tax revenue while placing almost no demand on schools, roads, or other public services. In Loudoun County, Virginia, data centers occupy roughly 4% of commercial land but generate 38% of general fund revenue, projected to reach nearly $1.3 billion in fiscal 2027. Without it, the county estimates residential property tax rates would need to rise 91%, about $5,800 a year for a typical homeowner.
"Voters' concerns about their power bills, their water, and the noise next door are real, and local leaders should take them seriously," said Fung. "But for communities that do move forward, the toolkit lays out how to get the most out of these deals. It's important to write the rules up front, make developers pay their own way, and make sure the neighbors who live closest to these facilities see the benefits first through enforceable commitments."
The report finds:
The report recommends that local governments publish data center ordinances and a standard term sheet that guarantees qualifying projects a decision within a fixed period, such as 60 or 90 days, instead of negotiating behind nondisclosure agreements; treat data center tax revenue as a windfall to fund capital projects, build reserves, and cut rates rather than recurring spending; and lock in ratepayer protections, water caps, noise limits, local hiring, and decommissioning bonds through enforceable development agreements and community benefits agreements. At a time of tight budgets and weak job markets, the report concludes, a good deal may beat an empty field.
Read and download the report here.
Founded in 1989, PPI is a catalyst for policy innovation and political reform based in Washington, D.C. Its mission is to create radically pragmatic ideas for moving America beyond ideological and partisan deadlock. Find an expert and learn more about PPI by visiting progressivepolicy.org. Follow us at @PPI.
***
Original text here: https://www.progressivepolicy.org/protecting-ratepayers-conserving-water-and-boosting-revenue-new-ppi-toolkit-shows-local-governments-how-to-make-ai-data-centers-pay-off-for-residents/ (TNSmrp)
* * *
Protecting Ratepayers, Conserving Water, and Boosting Revenue: New PPI Toolkit Shows Local Governments How to Make Data Centers Pay Off for Residents
*
Communities weighing whether to host data center developments can use a set of practical tools to protect residents on electricity bills, water use, and noise while boosting tax revenue, according to a new report from the Progressive Policy Institute (PPI).
Authored by Andrew Fung, Senior Economic and Technology Policy Analyst ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 [Category: ThinkTank] -- The Progressive Policy Institute posted the following news release: * * * Protecting Ratepayers, Conserving Water, and Boosting Revenue: New PPI Toolkit Shows Local Governments How to Make Data Centers Pay Off for Residents * Communities weighing whether to host data center developments can use a set of practical tools to protect residents on electricity bills, water use, and noise while boosting tax revenue, according to a new report from the Progressive Policy Institute (PPI). Authored by Andrew Fung, Senior Economic and Technology Policy Analystat PPI, and Maximillian Levin, Public Policy Fellow at PPI, "A Data Center Toolkit for Local Government" lays out four goals local leaders can pursue when negotiating with developers: increasing tax revenue, controlling electricity prices, conserving water, and limiting siting impacts while boosting community benefits. It concludes that localities that publish their terms in advance and approve projects that meet them on a fixed timeline can capture the benefits of the data center boom on their own terms, positioning themselves well to get a good deal.
Public concern about data centers is growing. Polling from Embold Research found that 70% of registered voters oppose building a data center in their area, up from 52% in December 2025, and in the 2026 midterms, voters in dozens of communities approved local measures banning or restricting the facilities. Between 30% and 50% of U.S. data center projects slated for 2026 are expected to be delayed or canceled, leaving $130 billion in capital spending on hold.
But for communities that choose to host facilities, the fiscal upside can be significant, the report argues. Data centers generate substantial property tax revenue while placing almost no demand on schools, roads, or other public services. In Loudoun County, Virginia, data centers occupy roughly 4% of commercial land but generate 38% of general fund revenue, projected to reach nearly $1.3 billion in fiscal 2027. Without it, the county estimates residential property tax rates would need to rise 91%, about $5,800 a year for a typical homeowner.
"Voters' concerns about their power bills, their water, and the noise next door are real, and local leaders should take them seriously," said Fung. "But for communities that do move forward, the toolkit lays out how to get the most out of these deals. It's important to write the rules up front, make developers pay their own way, and make sure the neighbors who live closest to these facilities see the benefits first through enforceable commitments."
The report finds:
The report recommends that local governments publish data center ordinances and a standard term sheet that guarantees qualifying projects a decision within a fixed period, such as 60 or 90 days, instead of negotiating behind nondisclosure agreements; treat data center tax revenue as a windfall to fund capital projects, build reserves, and cut rates rather than recurring spending; and lock in ratepayer protections, water caps, noise limits, local hiring, and decommissioning bonds through enforceable development agreements and community benefits agreements. At a time of tight budgets and weak job markets, the report concludes, a good deal may beat an empty field.
Read and download the report here.
Founded in 1989, PPI is a catalyst for policy innovation and political reform based in Washington, D.C. Its mission is to create radically pragmatic ideas for moving America beyond ideological and partisan deadlock. Find an expert and learn more about PPI by visiting progressivepolicy.org. Follow us at @PPI.
***
Original text here: https://www.progressivepolicy.org/protecting-ratepayers-conserving-water-and-boosting-revenue-new-ppi-toolkit-shows-local-governments-how-to-make-ai-data-centers-pay-off-for-residents/ (TNSmrp)
Jamestown Foundation Issues Commentary: Turkic Integration Deepens as Defense Cooperation Lags
WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Jamestown Foundation issued the following commentary on Nov. 18, 2026, in the foundation's Eurasia Daily Monitor:
* * *
Turkic Integration Deepens as Defense Cooperation Lags
11.18.2026
Vasif Huseynov
Executive summary:
* At the Organization of Turkic States (OTS) summit in Ankara on October 30, Turkiye took over the chairmanship from Azerbaijan, as cooperation expanded to some 60 areas, led by trade, transport, energy, and digital connectivity.
* Defense integration lags because Central Asian members, led by Kazakhstan, insist the OTS is not a military bloc. Astana's ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Jamestown Foundation issued the following commentary on Nov. 18, 2026, in the foundation's Eurasia Daily Monitor: * * * Turkic Integration Deepens as Defense Cooperation Lags 11.18.2026 Vasif Huseynov Executive summary: * At the Organization of Turkic States (OTS) summit in Ankara on October 30, Turkiye took over the chairmanship from Azerbaijan, as cooperation expanded to some 60 areas, led by trade, transport, energy, and digital connectivity. * Defense integration lags because Central Asian members, led by Kazakhstan, insist the OTS is not a military bloc. Astana'sproposal to involve Russia reflects multi-vector balancing, though OTS rules make Russian observer status unlikely.
* Azerbaijan has alliance treaties with all OTS member states, but only its alliance with Turkiye carries a mutual military assistance commitment, suggesting that defense cooperation in the Turkic world will remain largely bilateral for the foreseeable future.
-
On October 30, the Organization of Turkic States (OTS) held its 13th summit in Ankara under the theme "Turkic Century: Unity in Language, Thought and Deed." Azerbaijan handed over the rotating chairmanship to Turkiye. Kyrgyz President Sadyr Japarov praised Baku's tenure, while Uzbek President Shavkat Mirziyoyev thanked Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev for his contribution to the development of relations within the organization (1news.az, October 30). Speaking at the summit, Kazakh President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev noted that the work of OTS structures now covers some 60 areas of cooperation and called for clearer priorities and better coordination among its bodies (24KZ, October 30). Defense and security, however, lag behind the organization's overall momentum.
Azerbaijan has led the push to bring security onto the OTS agenda. At the 2023 Astana summit, Aliyev called for cooperation in defense and the defense industry, and the 2025 Gabala summit was held under the theme "Regional Peace and Security" (Trend News Agency, October 30). In Gabala, Aliyev stated that the OTS had evolved from a platform for cooperation into one of the world's significant geopolitical centers. He stressed that, at a time when the norms and principles of international law are being gravely violated, cooperation in the military and defense-technical fields has become crucial. Among other initiatives, he proposed holding a joint military exercise of member states in Azerbaijan in 2026, noting that Azerbaijan and Turkiye had conducted more than 25 bilateral and multinational exercises over the preceding year (President of Azerbaijan, October 7, 2025). These ideas have not translated into institutional formats yet, and military cooperation among Turkic states continues largely outside the OTS framework.
Central Asian capitals have been more reserved. At the informal OTS summit in Turkistan on May 15, Tokayev stated that the organization is neither a geopolitical project nor a military organization, describing it instead as a platform for trade, economic, high-tech, digital, cultural, and humanitarian cooperation (Interfax-Kazakhstan, May 15; Orda.kz, May 16). In Ankara, Tokayev reiterated that the OTS is not and should not become a military alliance, describing it as an open platform for cooperation that is not directed against other international associations (Zakon.kz, October 30).
These positions do not amount to a rejection of Turkic integration. Kazakhstan and its neighbors pursue balanced, multi-vector foreign policies shaped by geography and existing security arrangements. Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan remain members of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), and all Central Asian capitals place a premium on predictable relations with every major power in their neighborhood. For these states, adding a military dimension to the OTS could have implications well beyond the Turkic family.
Tokayev's proposal to involve Russia follows the same balancing logic. In Ankara, he proposed inviting Russia to cooperate with the organization in the OTS+ format launched in Gabala or to participate in its activities as an observer, arguing that this would strengthen the organization's authority (24KZ, October 30). Russian Presidential Press Secretary Dmitry Peskov described Russia's possible participation as expedient and natural, but noted that Moscow had received no invitation (NewTimes.kz, November 2). The initiative can be seen as another effort by Astana to soften perceptions of the OTS as a geopolitical project. While engagement through OTS+ is possible, observer status for Russia is unlikely. Under the rules adopted at the 2021 Istanbul summit, where the former Turkic Council was upgraded to the OTS, observer status is reserved for states that recognize a Turkic language as a state or official language nationwide (see EDM, November 17, 2021). Russian is the sole official language of the Russian Federation at the federal level, while Tatar, Bashkir, and other Turkic languages are state languages only in individual republics. Turkish Justice and Development Party (AKP) Deputy Chairman Kursad Zorlu likewise stressed that recognition of a Turkic language in individual regions is insufficient and that any Russian bid would require the approval of all member states (Hurriyet Daily News, November 4). Hungary's observer status, granted in 2018, predates these rules.
Central Asian reluctance concerns format rather than substance. Azerbaijani servicemen took part in the Birlestik-2024 exercise in Kazakhstan and the Birlik-2025 exercise in Uzbekistan alongside Kazakh, Kyrgyz, Tajik, and Uzbek forces (Report, July 9, 2024; Caspian Post, October 14, 2025). Central Asian states have also deepened bilateral defense ties with Turkiye. Kazakhstan's annual military cooperation plan with Ankara covers military education and combat training, while Uzbekistan's leadership has prioritized military-technical cooperation and the training of military specialists with Turkiye (The Astana Times, January 27, 2025; UzA, April 23). What remains politically sensitive is not defense cooperation itself, which is already underway, but placing it under the OTS umbrella.
The same pattern appears in Azerbaijan's treaty framework. Baku has alliance treaties with every OTS member. The 2005 Treaty on Strategic Partnership and Allied Relations with Kazakhstan marked its 20th anniversary during Aliyev's state visit to Astana (The Astana Times, October 21, 2025). Baku and Tashkent signed a Treaty on Allied Relations in 2024, which Uzbekistan ratified in May 2025 (Daryo, May 20, 2025). Azerbaijan and Kyrgyzstan signed a Treaty on Allied Relations on July 31 (Trend News Agency, July 31; see EDM, September 9). Only the 2021 Shusha Declaration with Turkiye, however, contains a mutual assistance commitment, under which Azerbaijan and Turkiye are to hold joint consultations and provide each other with the necessary assistance, in line with the UN Charter, if either faces a threat or act of aggression from a third state (President of Azerbaijan, June 15, 2021). In May 2025, Tashkent publicly denied reports that Uzbekistan had joined the Shusha Declaration (Kun.uz, May 26, 2025). The treaties with Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Kyrgyzstan are alliances of political trust and economic partnership rather than defense pacts, leaving the Azerbaijan-Turkiye alliance as the only relationship within the OTS with a full mutual security dimension.
None of this diminishes the value of the OTS for Central Asia, which lies primarily in connectivity. For landlocked Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Kyrgyzstan, it has become a practical framework for reaching global markets. The Middle Corridor connects Central Asia to Europe via Azerbaijan and Turkiye and has gained importance as an alternative to northern routes since 2022. Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, and Uzbekistan are jointly developing the Caspian Green Energy Corridor and signed a memorandum with the Asian Development Bank and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank in April 2025 to prepare its feasibility study (Kun.uz, April 7, 2025). In Turkistan, Tokayev himself proposed a network of artificial intelligence centers, joint space projects in satellite communications and navigation, and the mutual recognition of electronic documents and digital signatures (The Astana Times, May 15).
Sequencing matters in regional integration. European integration began with coal and steel, while a common defense policy emerged only decades later. The Turkic states appear to be following a comparable path, and the Central Asian members may need more time before institutionalizing defense cooperation within the OTS. Less sensitive steps, such as defense industry cooperation, military education exchanges, emergency response training, cybersecurity, and the protection of critical infrastructure along the Middle Corridor, remain within reach.
Turkiye's chairmanship offers an opportunity to advance this agenda incrementally, and Baku will remain one of the most consistent advocates of a stronger OTS, including in security matters. The direction of Turkic integration is clear. The pace of its defense dimension, however, will be set by what all members are prepared to accept and by the trust that deepening economic interdependence is already building.
* * *
Dr. Vasif Huseynov is a senior fellow at the Center of Analysis of International Relations (AIR Center) and Adjunct Lecturer at Khazar University in Baku, Azerbaijan.
* * *
The foregoing analysis and commentary published by The Jamestown Foundation are provided for informational purposes only and do not constitute legal, financial, intelligence, security, medical, diplomatic, or other professional advice. Readers should not act or rely on any content herein without seeking independent professional guidance appropriate to their circumstances. All analytical conclusions reflect information available at the time of writing and may be superseded by subsequent events; Jamestown undertakes no obligation to update published content. Jamestown does not warrant the accuracy, completeness, or continued availability of third-party sources cited in its publications. The views expressed by individual authors are their own and do not necessarily represent the positions of The Jamestown Foundation, its board, staff, funders, or advisors. Nothing in Jamestown's publications constitutes an endorsement of any government, organization, policy, product, or service. Jamestown's publications are protected by copyright; reproduction or redistribution without written permission is prohibited except as permitted by applicable law.
* * *
Original text here: https://jamestown.org/turkic-integration-deepens-as-defense-cooperation-lags/
[Category: ThinkTank]
* * *
Turkic Integration Deepens as Defense Cooperation Lags
11.18.2026
Vasif Huseynov
Executive summary:
* At the Organization of Turkic States (OTS) summit in Ankara on October 30, Turkiye took over the chairmanship from Azerbaijan, as cooperation expanded to some 60 areas, led by trade, transport, energy, and digital connectivity.
* Defense integration lags because Central Asian members, led by Kazakhstan, insist the OTS is not a military bloc. Astana's ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Jamestown Foundation issued the following commentary on Nov. 18, 2026, in the foundation's Eurasia Daily Monitor: * * * Turkic Integration Deepens as Defense Cooperation Lags 11.18.2026 Vasif Huseynov Executive summary: * At the Organization of Turkic States (OTS) summit in Ankara on October 30, Turkiye took over the chairmanship from Azerbaijan, as cooperation expanded to some 60 areas, led by trade, transport, energy, and digital connectivity. * Defense integration lags because Central Asian members, led by Kazakhstan, insist the OTS is not a military bloc. Astana'sproposal to involve Russia reflects multi-vector balancing, though OTS rules make Russian observer status unlikely.
* Azerbaijan has alliance treaties with all OTS member states, but only its alliance with Turkiye carries a mutual military assistance commitment, suggesting that defense cooperation in the Turkic world will remain largely bilateral for the foreseeable future.
-
On October 30, the Organization of Turkic States (OTS) held its 13th summit in Ankara under the theme "Turkic Century: Unity in Language, Thought and Deed." Azerbaijan handed over the rotating chairmanship to Turkiye. Kyrgyz President Sadyr Japarov praised Baku's tenure, while Uzbek President Shavkat Mirziyoyev thanked Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev for his contribution to the development of relations within the organization (1news.az, October 30). Speaking at the summit, Kazakh President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev noted that the work of OTS structures now covers some 60 areas of cooperation and called for clearer priorities and better coordination among its bodies (24KZ, October 30). Defense and security, however, lag behind the organization's overall momentum.
Azerbaijan has led the push to bring security onto the OTS agenda. At the 2023 Astana summit, Aliyev called for cooperation in defense and the defense industry, and the 2025 Gabala summit was held under the theme "Regional Peace and Security" (Trend News Agency, October 30). In Gabala, Aliyev stated that the OTS had evolved from a platform for cooperation into one of the world's significant geopolitical centers. He stressed that, at a time when the norms and principles of international law are being gravely violated, cooperation in the military and defense-technical fields has become crucial. Among other initiatives, he proposed holding a joint military exercise of member states in Azerbaijan in 2026, noting that Azerbaijan and Turkiye had conducted more than 25 bilateral and multinational exercises over the preceding year (President of Azerbaijan, October 7, 2025). These ideas have not translated into institutional formats yet, and military cooperation among Turkic states continues largely outside the OTS framework.
Central Asian capitals have been more reserved. At the informal OTS summit in Turkistan on May 15, Tokayev stated that the organization is neither a geopolitical project nor a military organization, describing it instead as a platform for trade, economic, high-tech, digital, cultural, and humanitarian cooperation (Interfax-Kazakhstan, May 15; Orda.kz, May 16). In Ankara, Tokayev reiterated that the OTS is not and should not become a military alliance, describing it as an open platform for cooperation that is not directed against other international associations (Zakon.kz, October 30).
These positions do not amount to a rejection of Turkic integration. Kazakhstan and its neighbors pursue balanced, multi-vector foreign policies shaped by geography and existing security arrangements. Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan remain members of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), and all Central Asian capitals place a premium on predictable relations with every major power in their neighborhood. For these states, adding a military dimension to the OTS could have implications well beyond the Turkic family.
Tokayev's proposal to involve Russia follows the same balancing logic. In Ankara, he proposed inviting Russia to cooperate with the organization in the OTS+ format launched in Gabala or to participate in its activities as an observer, arguing that this would strengthen the organization's authority (24KZ, October 30). Russian Presidential Press Secretary Dmitry Peskov described Russia's possible participation as expedient and natural, but noted that Moscow had received no invitation (NewTimes.kz, November 2). The initiative can be seen as another effort by Astana to soften perceptions of the OTS as a geopolitical project. While engagement through OTS+ is possible, observer status for Russia is unlikely. Under the rules adopted at the 2021 Istanbul summit, where the former Turkic Council was upgraded to the OTS, observer status is reserved for states that recognize a Turkic language as a state or official language nationwide (see EDM, November 17, 2021). Russian is the sole official language of the Russian Federation at the federal level, while Tatar, Bashkir, and other Turkic languages are state languages only in individual republics. Turkish Justice and Development Party (AKP) Deputy Chairman Kursad Zorlu likewise stressed that recognition of a Turkic language in individual regions is insufficient and that any Russian bid would require the approval of all member states (Hurriyet Daily News, November 4). Hungary's observer status, granted in 2018, predates these rules.
Central Asian reluctance concerns format rather than substance. Azerbaijani servicemen took part in the Birlestik-2024 exercise in Kazakhstan and the Birlik-2025 exercise in Uzbekistan alongside Kazakh, Kyrgyz, Tajik, and Uzbek forces (Report, July 9, 2024; Caspian Post, October 14, 2025). Central Asian states have also deepened bilateral defense ties with Turkiye. Kazakhstan's annual military cooperation plan with Ankara covers military education and combat training, while Uzbekistan's leadership has prioritized military-technical cooperation and the training of military specialists with Turkiye (The Astana Times, January 27, 2025; UzA, April 23). What remains politically sensitive is not defense cooperation itself, which is already underway, but placing it under the OTS umbrella.
The same pattern appears in Azerbaijan's treaty framework. Baku has alliance treaties with every OTS member. The 2005 Treaty on Strategic Partnership and Allied Relations with Kazakhstan marked its 20th anniversary during Aliyev's state visit to Astana (The Astana Times, October 21, 2025). Baku and Tashkent signed a Treaty on Allied Relations in 2024, which Uzbekistan ratified in May 2025 (Daryo, May 20, 2025). Azerbaijan and Kyrgyzstan signed a Treaty on Allied Relations on July 31 (Trend News Agency, July 31; see EDM, September 9). Only the 2021 Shusha Declaration with Turkiye, however, contains a mutual assistance commitment, under which Azerbaijan and Turkiye are to hold joint consultations and provide each other with the necessary assistance, in line with the UN Charter, if either faces a threat or act of aggression from a third state (President of Azerbaijan, June 15, 2021). In May 2025, Tashkent publicly denied reports that Uzbekistan had joined the Shusha Declaration (Kun.uz, May 26, 2025). The treaties with Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Kyrgyzstan are alliances of political trust and economic partnership rather than defense pacts, leaving the Azerbaijan-Turkiye alliance as the only relationship within the OTS with a full mutual security dimension.
None of this diminishes the value of the OTS for Central Asia, which lies primarily in connectivity. For landlocked Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Kyrgyzstan, it has become a practical framework for reaching global markets. The Middle Corridor connects Central Asia to Europe via Azerbaijan and Turkiye and has gained importance as an alternative to northern routes since 2022. Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, and Uzbekistan are jointly developing the Caspian Green Energy Corridor and signed a memorandum with the Asian Development Bank and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank in April 2025 to prepare its feasibility study (Kun.uz, April 7, 2025). In Turkistan, Tokayev himself proposed a network of artificial intelligence centers, joint space projects in satellite communications and navigation, and the mutual recognition of electronic documents and digital signatures (The Astana Times, May 15).
Sequencing matters in regional integration. European integration began with coal and steel, while a common defense policy emerged only decades later. The Turkic states appear to be following a comparable path, and the Central Asian members may need more time before institutionalizing defense cooperation within the OTS. Less sensitive steps, such as defense industry cooperation, military education exchanges, emergency response training, cybersecurity, and the protection of critical infrastructure along the Middle Corridor, remain within reach.
Turkiye's chairmanship offers an opportunity to advance this agenda incrementally, and Baku will remain one of the most consistent advocates of a stronger OTS, including in security matters. The direction of Turkic integration is clear. The pace of its defense dimension, however, will be set by what all members are prepared to accept and by the trust that deepening economic interdependence is already building.
* * *
Dr. Vasif Huseynov is a senior fellow at the Center of Analysis of International Relations (AIR Center) and Adjunct Lecturer at Khazar University in Baku, Azerbaijan.
* * *
The foregoing analysis and commentary published by The Jamestown Foundation are provided for informational purposes only and do not constitute legal, financial, intelligence, security, medical, diplomatic, or other professional advice. Readers should not act or rely on any content herein without seeking independent professional guidance appropriate to their circumstances. All analytical conclusions reflect information available at the time of writing and may be superseded by subsequent events; Jamestown undertakes no obligation to update published content. Jamestown does not warrant the accuracy, completeness, or continued availability of third-party sources cited in its publications. The views expressed by individual authors are their own and do not necessarily represent the positions of The Jamestown Foundation, its board, staff, funders, or advisors. Nothing in Jamestown's publications constitutes an endorsement of any government, organization, policy, product, or service. Jamestown's publications are protected by copyright; reproduction or redistribution without written permission is prohibited except as permitted by applicable law.
* * *
Original text here: https://jamestown.org/turkic-integration-deepens-as-defense-cooperation-lags/
[Category: ThinkTank]
Heritage Foundation Welcomes Patrick Davis as General Counsel
WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Heritage Foundation issued the following news release:
* * *
Heritage Foundation Welcomes Patrick Davis as General Counsel
Nov 17, 2026
WASHINGTON -- Today, The Heritage Foundation welcomed Patrick Davis as General Counsel to provide legal leadership and guidance to the Heritage enterprise.
Before joining Heritage, Davis served as the Senate-confirmed Assistant Attorney General at the U.S. Department of Justice, overseeing a large team of attorneys and managing the department's relationship with Congress, including the planning and enacting of strategies to advance ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Heritage Foundation issued the following news release: * * * Heritage Foundation Welcomes Patrick Davis as General Counsel Nov 17, 2026 WASHINGTON -- Today, The Heritage Foundation welcomed Patrick Davis as General Counsel to provide legal leadership and guidance to the Heritage enterprise. Before joining Heritage, Davis served as the Senate-confirmed Assistant Attorney General at the U.S. Department of Justice, overseeing a large team of attorneys and managing the department's relationship with Congress, including the planning and enacting of strategies to advancethe Trump administration's legislative priorities.
He brings decades of legal expertise to Heritage, having previously served as Senior Counsel at the American Petroleum Institute, Chief Investigative Counsel at the U.S. House of Representatives, Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, and Deputy Chief Investigative Counsel for the Senate Judiciary Committee.
With experience managing civil cases, constitutional claims, navigating congressional hearings and oversight strategies, and more, Davis makes an invaluable addition to the work and mission of The Heritage Foundation.
Patrick Davis remarked on his new position:
"It is an honor to join The Heritage Foundation and work alongside a world-class team committed to defending the Constitution and advancing conservative principles. I look forward to advancing Heritage's critical work by providing the legal counsel that helps us stay on offense, seize opportunities, move quickly and confidently, and deliver more wins for the American people."
Kevin Roberts, president and CEO of The Heritage Foundation and Heritage Action, welcomed Davis:
"We are thrilled to welcome Patrick Davis to the team. His extensive legal experience navigating the D.C. Swamp will be a crucial asset as Heritage accelerates its work to advance policies that benefit Americans and put their interests first in the years ahead."
Davis holds a Juris Doctor degree from Georgetown Law and is admitted to practice law in Washington, D.C., Virginia, and Nebraska.
* * *
Original text here: https://www.heritage.org/press/heritage-foundation-welcomes-patrick-davis-general-counsel
[Category: ThinkTank]
* * *
Heritage Foundation Welcomes Patrick Davis as General Counsel
Nov 17, 2026
WASHINGTON -- Today, The Heritage Foundation welcomed Patrick Davis as General Counsel to provide legal leadership and guidance to the Heritage enterprise.
Before joining Heritage, Davis served as the Senate-confirmed Assistant Attorney General at the U.S. Department of Justice, overseeing a large team of attorneys and managing the department's relationship with Congress, including the planning and enacting of strategies to advance ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Heritage Foundation issued the following news release: * * * Heritage Foundation Welcomes Patrick Davis as General Counsel Nov 17, 2026 WASHINGTON -- Today, The Heritage Foundation welcomed Patrick Davis as General Counsel to provide legal leadership and guidance to the Heritage enterprise. Before joining Heritage, Davis served as the Senate-confirmed Assistant Attorney General at the U.S. Department of Justice, overseeing a large team of attorneys and managing the department's relationship with Congress, including the planning and enacting of strategies to advancethe Trump administration's legislative priorities.
He brings decades of legal expertise to Heritage, having previously served as Senior Counsel at the American Petroleum Institute, Chief Investigative Counsel at the U.S. House of Representatives, Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, and Deputy Chief Investigative Counsel for the Senate Judiciary Committee.
With experience managing civil cases, constitutional claims, navigating congressional hearings and oversight strategies, and more, Davis makes an invaluable addition to the work and mission of The Heritage Foundation.
Patrick Davis remarked on his new position:
"It is an honor to join The Heritage Foundation and work alongside a world-class team committed to defending the Constitution and advancing conservative principles. I look forward to advancing Heritage's critical work by providing the legal counsel that helps us stay on offense, seize opportunities, move quickly and confidently, and deliver more wins for the American people."
Kevin Roberts, president and CEO of The Heritage Foundation and Heritage Action, welcomed Davis:
"We are thrilled to welcome Patrick Davis to the team. His extensive legal experience navigating the D.C. Swamp will be a crucial asset as Heritage accelerates its work to advance policies that benefit Americans and put their interests first in the years ahead."
Davis holds a Juris Doctor degree from Georgetown Law and is admitted to practice law in Washington, D.C., Virginia, and Nebraska.
* * *
Original text here: https://www.heritage.org/press/heritage-foundation-welcomes-patrick-davis-general-counsel
[Category: ThinkTank]
Center on Budget & Policy Priorities: Congress Must Enact Strong Guardrails for 2027 in Spending Bills to Rein in Administration Abuses
WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities issued the following report:
* * *
Congress Must Enact Strong Guardrails for 2027 in Spending Bills to Rein in Administration Abuses
November 18, 2026
Sam Berger, Sonali Master and Devin O'Connor
For the past two years, the Trump Administration has escalated its flagrant abuses of its funding authority to undermine Congress's constitutional power of the purse. It has unilaterally impounded funding approved by Congress, ignored congressional directives in funding laws, hollowed out agencies and programs that provide critical ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities issued the following report: * * * Congress Must Enact Strong Guardrails for 2027 in Spending Bills to Rein in Administration Abuses November 18, 2026 Sam Berger, Sonali Master and Devin O'Connor For the past two years, the Trump Administration has escalated its flagrant abuses of its funding authority to undermine Congress's constitutional power of the purse. It has unilaterally impounded funding approved by Congress, ignored congressional directives in funding laws, hollowed out agencies and programs that provide criticalservices communities depend on, and taken steps to dangerously politicize the federal grantmaking process. As Congress moves to provide final appropriations for fiscal year 2027, it is essential to include clear, robust, enforceable, government-wide guardrails to limit the Administration's abuses of federal funding.
Given the sharp rebuke delivered by voters to the Administration in the midterm elections over its corruption and abuses of power, the 2027 funding bills present an opportunity for Congress to take meaningful steps to address these issues.
This brief paper sets forth the broad-based guardrails that are most important for limiting illegal abuses of the funding power across government to ensure that Congress's directives, funding decisions, and authority are respected. Those guardrails would aim to:
* stop efforts to politicize federal grantmaking;
* ensure federal funds are not illegally impounded or rescinded;
* limit reorganizations or relocations intended to undermine federal agencies; and
* prevent the use of spurious fraud claims to justify withholding funding from perceived political opponents.
The Administration has also taken many troubling actions targeting specific government programs that would significantly change the impact of congressionally provided funding. For example, it has proposed regulations that would reduce the quality of services provided by Head Start and radically change the information collected by the Census. While this report does not discuss the full range of such problematic changes, Congress should address important policy issues like these in final appropriations as well.
2026 Appropriations Show Need for Clear, Enforceable, Government-Wide Protections
In providing final appropriations for fiscal year 2027, Congress should heed lessons from the 2026 appropriations process. Last year, Democratic House and Senate appropriators put forward legislation that included significant guardrails addressing many of the Administration's funding abuses, but they could not secure sufficient Republican support to enact these, or similar, protections.[1] Instead, despite the tools available to them, Congress moved forward with only a limited set of targeted protections for specific programs, some transparency measures, and non-binding expressions of concern about Administration actions. For example, Congress included provisions requiring grant funding for a few specific programs to be sent out by a date certain, requiring transparency around Administration actions to terminate funding in specific programs, and directing certain agencies to maintain sufficient staff to carry out statutory responsibilities.
Overall, these measures have failed to prevent the Administration from escalating its funding abuses over the past year. While some had an impact on specific programs at times, they did not prevent the Administration from engaging in significant abuses in other areas to which these provisions did not apply. Moreover, where provisions lacked enforcement mechanisms or were only non-binding exhortations in report language, the Administration frequently ignored them.
Guardrails remain a critical tool to protect Congress's power of the purse against the Administration's actions. The lesson from the past year, however, is that guardrails are only effective when they are clear, in statutory language (not in non-binding report language, which was often sufficient in past administrations), and enforceable. They also should be government-wide to the greatest extent possible, given the Administration's track record of seeking to abuse its power wherever its efforts are unchecked. Even when the Administration seeks to illegally ignore appropriations guardrails, making them both clear and enforceable will aid litigants in stopping the Administration in court. Beyond specific guardrails, these appropriations bills in general should be written in ways that reduce executive branch discretion over how funding is allocated, including by not relying on non-binding report language.
Essential Guardrails in Four Critical Areas
In establishing robust guardrails that protect against Administration abuses of funding power, lawmakers should prioritize guardrails that address the most widespread and harmful Administration abuses. These guardrails should:
Prevent the politicization of grantmaking. The Administration has sought to undermine and politicize the grantmaking process, which affects billions of dollars flowing to states, localities, and institutions to support scientific research, public safety, and other key community functions.
The most significant such effort is a recent proposed rule from the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) that would politicize both how grants recipients are selected and when their grants can be cancelled.[2] It would pose significant threats to scientific funding, public health and safety programs, and communities served by federal grant funding across the nation. Pushback to the proposed rule was widespread, and Congress included a provision in the temporary spending measure for fiscal year 2027 that prevents the rule from going into effect through December 11, 2026.
In the short term, Congress must at least extend this prohibition for the duration of any continuing resolution. But to address the issue permanently, Congress will need to ban finalization of the rule and any similar agency efforts in 2027 appropriations legislation.
The Administration has also proposed adding coercive new requirements to the SAM.gov (System for Award Management) annual certification processes. These changes would -- without any legal basis or authorization -- require more than 200,000 federal award recipients to certify compliance with the Administration's legally controversial and overly broad executive orders related to immigration and diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), among other areas.[3] Congress should also prohibit the implementation of this or any similar proposal.
In addition, the Administration has used the grantmaking process to target perceived political opponents and coerce grant recipients to take unrelated policy actions. For example, when a political ally of the President was convicted and jailed for election machine tampering in Colorado, the President publicly threatened consequences for the state if it did not release her. Following her conviction, the White House sent a non-public directive to federal agencies to "prioritize Colorado for the purposes of ensuring grants and federal support are in line with administration priorities."[4] Shortly thereafter, the Department of Transportation announced it was cancelling over $100 million in grant projects in Colorado.[5] Congress should establish significant penalties for political appointees who engage in such coercive abuse of federal grantmaking authority.
Stop illegal impoundments, including pocket rescissions. The Administration continues to ignore spending laws by withholding federal funds.[6] Among many egregious and illegal impoundments, the Administration has, for the second fiscal year in a row, declared that it is unilaterally causing funds to expire at the end of the fiscal year, which it terms a "pocket rescission."[7] The Government Accountability Office, members of Congress from both parties, and the courts have all agreed the Administration's actions are illegal.
There are a range of steps Congress can take to prevent these illegal pocket rescissions. They include proposals put forward by the Democratic leaders of the appropriations committees in 2025 that would turn off the Administration's ability to send late-year rescission requests, which the Administration claims -- without legal basis -- justifies their impoundment of funds.
In addition, Congress should take steps to prevent impoundments beyond the Administration's illegal pocket rescissions by requiring that the Administration meet key funding milestones, including deadlines for making funds available for obligation, for running funding competitions, and for making awards. This would build on and expand the scope of the targeted requirements enacted in 2026 appropriations. Congress could also take steps to make it easier to challenge the illegal withholding of funds in court.
Block destructive agency reorganizations and staff relocations. The Administration continues to ignore congressional directives (some in law but many in non-binding report language) in its efforts to hinder or harm programs it disfavors by restructuring federal agencies, closing offices or facilities, and seeking to punitively relocate federal personnel. Many of these efforts have targeted programs or offices that the Administration sought to cut funding for, but had its efforts rebuffed by Congress.
For example, the Administration has illegally transferred certain functions from the Education Department to other departments and agencies through an abuse of interagency agreements. The Administration has also taken unilateral actions to move offices and staff to undermine programs despite ongoing congressional support.[8] The U.S. Forest Service, for example, has announced plans to close three-quarters of its research facilities and relocate its headquarters staff to Salt Lake City. This would likely cause significant numbers of experienced staff to leave federal service, undermining the agency's capacity to deliver on the tasks Congress requires it to undertake.[9]
Congress should take further action to unwind the specific efforts the Administration has announced or undertaken by mandating, in statutory language, that various programs and duties be located in specific agencies or that those agencies not relocate offices or staff. Congress can also prevent similar abuses in the future by making the appropriations bills themselves far more prescriptive and limiting how interagency agreements can be used.
Prevent the weaponization of fraud claims to withhold funding. The Administration continues to rely on unsubstantiated claims of fraud as a pretext for withholding funding from disfavored states and other grantees for unrelated political reasons. For example, in January 2026, OMB sent a letter to five Democratic-led states freezing funding for programs that support people with low incomes, alleging that it had "serious concerns about widespread fraud."[10] However, OMB provided no evidence supporting its claims and a federal judge later blocked the action, finding that the Administration had acted contrary to law.
Congress should take steps to limit the Administration's ability to abuse these authorities to inappropriately target fund recipients and delay critical funding. Such steps could include providing clearer standards to invoke these authorities, opportunities for funding delays to be more easily challenged in a timely manner, and clear penalties for abusing these authorities.
* * *
Figure 1: Strong Guardrails Needed for 2027 to Rein in Administration Funding Abuses
* * *
Sam Berger
Sam is a Senior Fellow on the Federal Fiscal Policy team. Prior to his work at CBPP, Sam served as Associate Administrator of the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs in the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and as Director of Strategic Operations and Policy for the White House COVID-19 Response Team.
Devin O'Connor
Devin is a Senior Fellow on the Federal Fiscal Policy team. Prior to joining the Center, Devin served as the White House Senior Advisor for American Rescue Plan Implementation and as the Chief Economic Advisor on the White House American Rescue Plan Implementation Team.
Sonali Master is a Research Associate with the Federal Fiscal Policy team. She also currently serves as an Intern Coordinator.
* * *
Original text here: https://www.cbpp.org/research/governance/congress-must-enact-strong-guardrails-for-2027-in-spending-bills-to-rein-in
[Category: ThinkTank]
* * *
Congress Must Enact Strong Guardrails for 2027 in Spending Bills to Rein in Administration Abuses
November 18, 2026
Sam Berger, Sonali Master and Devin O'Connor
For the past two years, the Trump Administration has escalated its flagrant abuses of its funding authority to undermine Congress's constitutional power of the purse. It has unilaterally impounded funding approved by Congress, ignored congressional directives in funding laws, hollowed out agencies and programs that provide critical ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities issued the following report: * * * Congress Must Enact Strong Guardrails for 2027 in Spending Bills to Rein in Administration Abuses November 18, 2026 Sam Berger, Sonali Master and Devin O'Connor For the past two years, the Trump Administration has escalated its flagrant abuses of its funding authority to undermine Congress's constitutional power of the purse. It has unilaterally impounded funding approved by Congress, ignored congressional directives in funding laws, hollowed out agencies and programs that provide criticalservices communities depend on, and taken steps to dangerously politicize the federal grantmaking process. As Congress moves to provide final appropriations for fiscal year 2027, it is essential to include clear, robust, enforceable, government-wide guardrails to limit the Administration's abuses of federal funding.
Given the sharp rebuke delivered by voters to the Administration in the midterm elections over its corruption and abuses of power, the 2027 funding bills present an opportunity for Congress to take meaningful steps to address these issues.
This brief paper sets forth the broad-based guardrails that are most important for limiting illegal abuses of the funding power across government to ensure that Congress's directives, funding decisions, and authority are respected. Those guardrails would aim to:
* stop efforts to politicize federal grantmaking;
* ensure federal funds are not illegally impounded or rescinded;
* limit reorganizations or relocations intended to undermine federal agencies; and
* prevent the use of spurious fraud claims to justify withholding funding from perceived political opponents.
The Administration has also taken many troubling actions targeting specific government programs that would significantly change the impact of congressionally provided funding. For example, it has proposed regulations that would reduce the quality of services provided by Head Start and radically change the information collected by the Census. While this report does not discuss the full range of such problematic changes, Congress should address important policy issues like these in final appropriations as well.
2026 Appropriations Show Need for Clear, Enforceable, Government-Wide Protections
In providing final appropriations for fiscal year 2027, Congress should heed lessons from the 2026 appropriations process. Last year, Democratic House and Senate appropriators put forward legislation that included significant guardrails addressing many of the Administration's funding abuses, but they could not secure sufficient Republican support to enact these, or similar, protections.[1] Instead, despite the tools available to them, Congress moved forward with only a limited set of targeted protections for specific programs, some transparency measures, and non-binding expressions of concern about Administration actions. For example, Congress included provisions requiring grant funding for a few specific programs to be sent out by a date certain, requiring transparency around Administration actions to terminate funding in specific programs, and directing certain agencies to maintain sufficient staff to carry out statutory responsibilities.
Overall, these measures have failed to prevent the Administration from escalating its funding abuses over the past year. While some had an impact on specific programs at times, they did not prevent the Administration from engaging in significant abuses in other areas to which these provisions did not apply. Moreover, where provisions lacked enforcement mechanisms or were only non-binding exhortations in report language, the Administration frequently ignored them.
Guardrails remain a critical tool to protect Congress's power of the purse against the Administration's actions. The lesson from the past year, however, is that guardrails are only effective when they are clear, in statutory language (not in non-binding report language, which was often sufficient in past administrations), and enforceable. They also should be government-wide to the greatest extent possible, given the Administration's track record of seeking to abuse its power wherever its efforts are unchecked. Even when the Administration seeks to illegally ignore appropriations guardrails, making them both clear and enforceable will aid litigants in stopping the Administration in court. Beyond specific guardrails, these appropriations bills in general should be written in ways that reduce executive branch discretion over how funding is allocated, including by not relying on non-binding report language.
Essential Guardrails in Four Critical Areas
In establishing robust guardrails that protect against Administration abuses of funding power, lawmakers should prioritize guardrails that address the most widespread and harmful Administration abuses. These guardrails should:
Prevent the politicization of grantmaking. The Administration has sought to undermine and politicize the grantmaking process, which affects billions of dollars flowing to states, localities, and institutions to support scientific research, public safety, and other key community functions.
The most significant such effort is a recent proposed rule from the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) that would politicize both how grants recipients are selected and when their grants can be cancelled.[2] It would pose significant threats to scientific funding, public health and safety programs, and communities served by federal grant funding across the nation. Pushback to the proposed rule was widespread, and Congress included a provision in the temporary spending measure for fiscal year 2027 that prevents the rule from going into effect through December 11, 2026.
In the short term, Congress must at least extend this prohibition for the duration of any continuing resolution. But to address the issue permanently, Congress will need to ban finalization of the rule and any similar agency efforts in 2027 appropriations legislation.
The Administration has also proposed adding coercive new requirements to the SAM.gov (System for Award Management) annual certification processes. These changes would -- without any legal basis or authorization -- require more than 200,000 federal award recipients to certify compliance with the Administration's legally controversial and overly broad executive orders related to immigration and diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), among other areas.[3] Congress should also prohibit the implementation of this or any similar proposal.
In addition, the Administration has used the grantmaking process to target perceived political opponents and coerce grant recipients to take unrelated policy actions. For example, when a political ally of the President was convicted and jailed for election machine tampering in Colorado, the President publicly threatened consequences for the state if it did not release her. Following her conviction, the White House sent a non-public directive to federal agencies to "prioritize Colorado for the purposes of ensuring grants and federal support are in line with administration priorities."[4] Shortly thereafter, the Department of Transportation announced it was cancelling over $100 million in grant projects in Colorado.[5] Congress should establish significant penalties for political appointees who engage in such coercive abuse of federal grantmaking authority.
Stop illegal impoundments, including pocket rescissions. The Administration continues to ignore spending laws by withholding federal funds.[6] Among many egregious and illegal impoundments, the Administration has, for the second fiscal year in a row, declared that it is unilaterally causing funds to expire at the end of the fiscal year, which it terms a "pocket rescission."[7] The Government Accountability Office, members of Congress from both parties, and the courts have all agreed the Administration's actions are illegal.
There are a range of steps Congress can take to prevent these illegal pocket rescissions. They include proposals put forward by the Democratic leaders of the appropriations committees in 2025 that would turn off the Administration's ability to send late-year rescission requests, which the Administration claims -- without legal basis -- justifies their impoundment of funds.
In addition, Congress should take steps to prevent impoundments beyond the Administration's illegal pocket rescissions by requiring that the Administration meet key funding milestones, including deadlines for making funds available for obligation, for running funding competitions, and for making awards. This would build on and expand the scope of the targeted requirements enacted in 2026 appropriations. Congress could also take steps to make it easier to challenge the illegal withholding of funds in court.
Block destructive agency reorganizations and staff relocations. The Administration continues to ignore congressional directives (some in law but many in non-binding report language) in its efforts to hinder or harm programs it disfavors by restructuring federal agencies, closing offices or facilities, and seeking to punitively relocate federal personnel. Many of these efforts have targeted programs or offices that the Administration sought to cut funding for, but had its efforts rebuffed by Congress.
For example, the Administration has illegally transferred certain functions from the Education Department to other departments and agencies through an abuse of interagency agreements. The Administration has also taken unilateral actions to move offices and staff to undermine programs despite ongoing congressional support.[8] The U.S. Forest Service, for example, has announced plans to close three-quarters of its research facilities and relocate its headquarters staff to Salt Lake City. This would likely cause significant numbers of experienced staff to leave federal service, undermining the agency's capacity to deliver on the tasks Congress requires it to undertake.[9]
Congress should take further action to unwind the specific efforts the Administration has announced or undertaken by mandating, in statutory language, that various programs and duties be located in specific agencies or that those agencies not relocate offices or staff. Congress can also prevent similar abuses in the future by making the appropriations bills themselves far more prescriptive and limiting how interagency agreements can be used.
Prevent the weaponization of fraud claims to withhold funding. The Administration continues to rely on unsubstantiated claims of fraud as a pretext for withholding funding from disfavored states and other grantees for unrelated political reasons. For example, in January 2026, OMB sent a letter to five Democratic-led states freezing funding for programs that support people with low incomes, alleging that it had "serious concerns about widespread fraud."[10] However, OMB provided no evidence supporting its claims and a federal judge later blocked the action, finding that the Administration had acted contrary to law.
Congress should take steps to limit the Administration's ability to abuse these authorities to inappropriately target fund recipients and delay critical funding. Such steps could include providing clearer standards to invoke these authorities, opportunities for funding delays to be more easily challenged in a timely manner, and clear penalties for abusing these authorities.
* * *
Figure 1: Strong Guardrails Needed for 2027 to Rein in Administration Funding Abuses
* * *
Sam Berger
Sam is a Senior Fellow on the Federal Fiscal Policy team. Prior to his work at CBPP, Sam served as Associate Administrator of the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs in the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and as Director of Strategic Operations and Policy for the White House COVID-19 Response Team.
Devin O'Connor
Devin is a Senior Fellow on the Federal Fiscal Policy team. Prior to joining the Center, Devin served as the White House Senior Advisor for American Rescue Plan Implementation and as the Chief Economic Advisor on the White House American Rescue Plan Implementation Team.
Sonali Master is a Research Associate with the Federal Fiscal Policy team. She also currently serves as an Intern Coordinator.
* * *
Original text here: https://www.cbpp.org/research/governance/congress-must-enact-strong-guardrails-for-2027-in-spending-bills-to-rein-in
[Category: ThinkTank]
Center of the American Experiment Issues Commentary: Polycule Leaders' Medicare Fraud Trial is Wrapping Up
MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 19 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary:
* * *
Written by Bill Glahn
November 18, 2026
Polycule leaders' Medicare fraud trial is wrapping up
The federal fraud trial of Gabriel Luthor and Elizabeth Brown is wrapping up in St. Paul. The pair are accused of orchestrating a $15 million Medicare fraud involving their Golden Victory Medical company.. Your correspondent was there.
I wrote about the case earlier this month. Luthor and Brown are said to ... Show Full Article MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 19 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary: * * * Written by Bill Glahn November 18, 2026 Polycule leaders' Medicare fraud trial is wrapping up The federal fraud trial of Gabriel Luthor and Elizabeth Brown is wrapping up in St. Paul. The pair are accused of orchestrating a $15 million Medicare fraud involving their Golden Victory Medical company.. Your correspondent was there. I wrote about the case earlier this month. Luthor and Brown are said tohave been in a polyamorous relationship with a handful of others, all living together in this million-dollar Eden Prairie mansion.
The two are accused of stealing $15 million from Medicare through their neurofeedback therapy practice based both here in Minnesota and in Las Vegas, Nevada.
Each defendant is separately represented, and the defense strategy for both appears to be to blame the other.
KARE-11's Lou Raguse was in court and has more details (https://x.com/LouNewsMan/status/2123216678142247381).
The jury trial was scheduled to run up until Thanksgiving but looks like it will finish this week. Both sides have rested their cases and closing arguments are set for tomorrow (Thursday) morning.
Today, the jury heard testimony from a lead government witness. A reference was made in a trial exhibit, apparently, to a Rolls Royce automobile. Testimony was also presented on $400,000 wired to the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Both are charged with six counts of wire fraud and one count of money laundering.
* * *
Bill Glahn is a Policy Fellow with Center of the American Experiment.
* * *
Original text here: https://www.americanexperiment.org/polycule-leaders-medicare-fraud-trial-is-wrapping-up/
[Category: ThinkTank]
* * *
Written by Bill Glahn
November 18, 2026
Polycule leaders' Medicare fraud trial is wrapping up
The federal fraud trial of Gabriel Luthor and Elizabeth Brown is wrapping up in St. Paul. The pair are accused of orchestrating a $15 million Medicare fraud involving their Golden Victory Medical company.. Your correspondent was there.
I wrote about the case earlier this month. Luthor and Brown are said to ... Show Full Article MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 19 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary: * * * Written by Bill Glahn November 18, 2026 Polycule leaders' Medicare fraud trial is wrapping up The federal fraud trial of Gabriel Luthor and Elizabeth Brown is wrapping up in St. Paul. The pair are accused of orchestrating a $15 million Medicare fraud involving their Golden Victory Medical company.. Your correspondent was there. I wrote about the case earlier this month. Luthor and Brown are said tohave been in a polyamorous relationship with a handful of others, all living together in this million-dollar Eden Prairie mansion.
The two are accused of stealing $15 million from Medicare through their neurofeedback therapy practice based both here in Minnesota and in Las Vegas, Nevada.
Each defendant is separately represented, and the defense strategy for both appears to be to blame the other.
KARE-11's Lou Raguse was in court and has more details (https://x.com/LouNewsMan/status/2123216678142247381).
The jury trial was scheduled to run up until Thanksgiving but looks like it will finish this week. Both sides have rested their cases and closing arguments are set for tomorrow (Thursday) morning.
Today, the jury heard testimony from a lead government witness. A reference was made in a trial exhibit, apparently, to a Rolls Royce automobile. Testimony was also presented on $400,000 wired to the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Both are charged with six counts of wire fraud and one count of money laundering.
* * *
Bill Glahn is a Policy Fellow with Center of the American Experiment.
* * *
Original text here: https://www.americanexperiment.org/polycule-leaders-medicare-fraud-trial-is-wrapping-up/
[Category: ThinkTank]
CSIS Issues Newsletter: Human Rights Initiative Director's Note - November 2026 Edition
WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Center for Strategic and International Studies issued the following newsletter:
* * *
Human Rights Initiative Director's Note: November 2026 Edition
by Andrew Friedman
November 18, 2026
Welcome to the November 2026 edition of the Human Rights Initiative Director's Note. I'm Andrew Friedman, director and senior fellow of the Human Rights Initiative (HRI) at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). I produce this outlet monthly to talk through human rights and democracy issues that have been occupying significant space in my mind, highlight some of ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Center for Strategic and International Studies issued the following newsletter: * * * Human Rights Initiative Director's Note: November 2026 Edition by Andrew Friedman November 18, 2026 Welcome to the November 2026 edition of the Human Rights Initiative Director's Note. I'm Andrew Friedman, director and senior fellow of the Human Rights Initiative (HRI) at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). I produce this outlet monthly to talk through human rights and democracy issues that have been occupying significant space in my mind, highlight some ofwhat we've been doing at HRI, and present a few articles, books, podcasts, and/or videos that have particularly struck me over the last few weeks.
What I'm Thinking About
"Is democracy a goal or a tool?" This question was posed to the gathered democracy advocates by Taro Kono, former foreign minister of Japan, at the Copenhagen Democracy Summit earlier this year. Since that time, it has rung through my head, and never more than over the last few weeks.
Much of the political conversation in the United States right now is around whether a new Congress and governments in years to come should focus on delivery or accountability. That is, should the main goal be to deliver for the American people and look forward (democracy as a tool), or should there be investigations and focus on how we got here (democracy as a goal)?
Minister Kono isn't the first to pose a version of this question. There has long been a debate in pro-democracy circles about whether individuals sour on democracy when it doesn't "deliver" or if other forces are at play. Sure, in the medium to long term, the evidence is clear--democracy brings better health outcomes, more economic development, greater security, and countless other metrics for objectively improved human existence--but that's the medium to long term. To defend democracy in the short term, the argument goes, new democratic systems have to prove their worth to the people, and quickly. This time frame shortens when countries are at particular risk of coups or other extraconstitutional means of changing governments, whether that's because they have a history of coups or they see them in their neighborhood.
Democracy advocates believed in this framework strongly enough that USAID, before its dismantling, launched an initiative around it, aiming to mobilize funds and stakeholders to support democratic openings around the world. It was creatively called "Democracy Delivers."
My two cents? "Yes, and." People respond viscerally to those trying to take away their democratic rights, but they also respond viscerally to an inability to envision a better life for their kids, whether that's because there's too few jobs, no healthcare, or insecurity. The most interesting data I've ever seen on the topic is from Afrobarometer, which found citizens became dissatisfied with how democracy performed when they perceived declines in socioeconomic and political performance, but declines in support for democracy as a system were "most closely linked to adverse changes in political performance, such as declining election quality, increasing levels of corruption, and failure to promote the rule of law." Put differently, governments failing at human development indicators make people angry at the function of their democracy, but disenfranchisement of voters and not seeing corrupt leaders held accountable makes them question the whole system.
That brings us back to Minister Kono's provocative question. Is the point of democracy to have individuals play a role in the decisions that most impact their lives, or is it to facilitate greater human development? I've talked a lot about elections in this note--what they mean, how they feel, how chaotic and/or beautiful they can be--but this question goes to the heart of choices made after elections. If democracy is a goal, then policy decisions should prioritize deepening democracy and ensuring its survival. If it's a tool, the priority should be to use its responsiveness for human development.
Back to my "yes, and" answer: I think there's a middle ground that treats it as both and works towards both outcomes. The Afrobarometer data is telling. People get concerned about the function of their democracy when they can't put food on the table. People turn against democracy as a system when they see corruption and a lack of accountability. This points to an approach that delivers, using democracy as a tool, while sharpening that tool to make sure it works and people still want to use it (as a goal).
Countering corruption, and ensuring corrupt actors are held accountable, is at the center of this "yes, and" approach. Corruption isn't an incomprehensible sum that finds itself in the bank account of a distant oligarch. Corruption is a hospital that doesn't have medicine or a road that doesn't get built. Corruption is a food company paying to avoid health inspections, either making people sick or ending up with a recall that limits the supply, making food more expensive for everyone. In recent polling, 81 percent of Americans see "corruption as raising [their] costs personally."
It's easy to see these as separate issues in their extremes: as a goal when people in autocracies are fighting against impossible odds to hold their leaders to account, or when individuals in established democracies are fighting for that "more perfect" part of the union; as a tool when jobs and food are scarce and healthcare is out of reach in democracies and it's time to pick leaders who craft more responsive policies.
Like any goal, it needs to be sought, and like any tool, it needs to be used and maintained. That means policy approaches should aim to improve and consolidate democracy, but also to use it to improve lives while maintaining support for it. It helps that many of the policies that seek the goal of a more democratic world also maintain the tool itself. Improving commitment to the rule of law and rooting out corruption improve people's perception of democracy as a system while also creating a more functioning democracy. A more functional tool leads to better outcomes, as democracy is more responsive and accountable and can lead to better policies.
What We're Doing
How Can the Future of AI Center Human Rights? - As part of our Tech for Good, Tech for Bad initiative, we hosted an event examining how AI can center human rights. I was joined by Sarah Yager from OpenAI and Jason Pielemeier from the Global Network Initiative for the discussion. A major theme of the discussion was the ability to adapt human rights law, principles, and approaches to AI. Sure, there is much that's new about the technology, but human rights has adapted to new technology before, and figuring out what is adaptable versus what is truly novel will be a key issue in centering human rights in AI. Come for the human rights in AI conversation, stay for a truly incredible philosophical point made by Sarah.
Reimagining the Atrocities Prevention Law and Policy Architecture in the U.S. - On October 23, the Alliance for Peacebuilding hosted a full-day conference about the future of atrocity prevention work within the U.S. government. It was a fascinating series of conversations, and one of the main takeaways (which is true for all development work) is that it's not a time to be thinking in predefined boxes, and the realm of the possible is never going to be the same as it was a few years ago, for both better and worse. It's an important time to be reimagining what we can do and how we can do it better, rather than assuming what couldbe. A huge thanks to AfP and Megan Corrado for putting on this event, making sure the community stays together and keeps thinking about what could be.
What I'm Reading (and Watching)
Civic Space is Still Contested, but Not Yet Lost. It's Time for the Big Pivot - Vukasin Petrovic - About a year ago I met with Vukasin, and as we chatted, he posed a fascinating question: What would an offensive civic space look like? For too long, civil society has been on the back foot. Civic space is closing and resources have been stripped away. Authoritarians are emboldened with new tactics in both the online and offline realms. So how does civil society go on the offensive? How can those doing the hard work pivot from defense to offense? This article goes a long way in addressing that question.
Reimagining how the United States advances development in the 21st century: At home and overseas - Ambassador Sarah Mendelson - One of the primary lessons of USAID's dismantling is the immense disconnect between Americans whose primary work is overseas and communities across the U.S. Changing this should be one of the most pressing priorities for any future U.S. development efforts. Ambassador Mendelson (the inaugural director of HRI!) here makes the case for having a "Development Officer Corps" with domestic tours as well as international ones. This could bring needed innovation and cross learning to development efforts, make sure the work is better understood by and ingrained in domestic communities, and help break down the silos that are too common between domestic and foreign affairs. Removing this imaginary barrier is key to a more sustainable future.
Special Bonus (because I haven't read it yet): Education and Conflict in Northeast Nigeria - Dr. Vanita Datta - Alright, alright, alright. I haven't read this one yet, but I got a chance to hear about the research and drafting extensively during the process. Vanita is a good friend and a former colleague, and she just released a book based on her PhD research. Her deep knowledge of what conflict in West Africa means to development outcomes is unmatched, and I have no doubt it comes through here.
We'll be back in December, but until then, keep up with our goings-on on the HRI homepage and on LinkedIn. If you have thoughts or questions, please feel free to reach out at afriedman@csis.org, and if you were forwarded this and enjoyed it, please sign up via the homepage here (https://pardot.csis.org/e/906722/ograms-human-rights-initiative/3tbgqn/4082720440/h/XZlFVEApvbNwNESATpj_F050bBi4ha9s_3JPkz6TRF4).
* * *
Original text here: https://www.csis.org/analysis/human-rights-initiative-directors-note-november-2026-edition
[Category: ThinkTank]
* * *
Human Rights Initiative Director's Note: November 2026 Edition
by Andrew Friedman
November 18, 2026
Welcome to the November 2026 edition of the Human Rights Initiative Director's Note. I'm Andrew Friedman, director and senior fellow of the Human Rights Initiative (HRI) at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). I produce this outlet monthly to talk through human rights and democracy issues that have been occupying significant space in my mind, highlight some of ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 19 -- The Center for Strategic and International Studies issued the following newsletter: * * * Human Rights Initiative Director's Note: November 2026 Edition by Andrew Friedman November 18, 2026 Welcome to the November 2026 edition of the Human Rights Initiative Director's Note. I'm Andrew Friedman, director and senior fellow of the Human Rights Initiative (HRI) at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). I produce this outlet monthly to talk through human rights and democracy issues that have been occupying significant space in my mind, highlight some ofwhat we've been doing at HRI, and present a few articles, books, podcasts, and/or videos that have particularly struck me over the last few weeks.
What I'm Thinking About
"Is democracy a goal or a tool?" This question was posed to the gathered democracy advocates by Taro Kono, former foreign minister of Japan, at the Copenhagen Democracy Summit earlier this year. Since that time, it has rung through my head, and never more than over the last few weeks.
Much of the political conversation in the United States right now is around whether a new Congress and governments in years to come should focus on delivery or accountability. That is, should the main goal be to deliver for the American people and look forward (democracy as a tool), or should there be investigations and focus on how we got here (democracy as a goal)?
Minister Kono isn't the first to pose a version of this question. There has long been a debate in pro-democracy circles about whether individuals sour on democracy when it doesn't "deliver" or if other forces are at play. Sure, in the medium to long term, the evidence is clear--democracy brings better health outcomes, more economic development, greater security, and countless other metrics for objectively improved human existence--but that's the medium to long term. To defend democracy in the short term, the argument goes, new democratic systems have to prove their worth to the people, and quickly. This time frame shortens when countries are at particular risk of coups or other extraconstitutional means of changing governments, whether that's because they have a history of coups or they see them in their neighborhood.
Democracy advocates believed in this framework strongly enough that USAID, before its dismantling, launched an initiative around it, aiming to mobilize funds and stakeholders to support democratic openings around the world. It was creatively called "Democracy Delivers."
My two cents? "Yes, and." People respond viscerally to those trying to take away their democratic rights, but they also respond viscerally to an inability to envision a better life for their kids, whether that's because there's too few jobs, no healthcare, or insecurity. The most interesting data I've ever seen on the topic is from Afrobarometer, which found citizens became dissatisfied with how democracy performed when they perceived declines in socioeconomic and political performance, but declines in support for democracy as a system were "most closely linked to adverse changes in political performance, such as declining election quality, increasing levels of corruption, and failure to promote the rule of law." Put differently, governments failing at human development indicators make people angry at the function of their democracy, but disenfranchisement of voters and not seeing corrupt leaders held accountable makes them question the whole system.
That brings us back to Minister Kono's provocative question. Is the point of democracy to have individuals play a role in the decisions that most impact their lives, or is it to facilitate greater human development? I've talked a lot about elections in this note--what they mean, how they feel, how chaotic and/or beautiful they can be--but this question goes to the heart of choices made after elections. If democracy is a goal, then policy decisions should prioritize deepening democracy and ensuring its survival. If it's a tool, the priority should be to use its responsiveness for human development.
Back to my "yes, and" answer: I think there's a middle ground that treats it as both and works towards both outcomes. The Afrobarometer data is telling. People get concerned about the function of their democracy when they can't put food on the table. People turn against democracy as a system when they see corruption and a lack of accountability. This points to an approach that delivers, using democracy as a tool, while sharpening that tool to make sure it works and people still want to use it (as a goal).
Countering corruption, and ensuring corrupt actors are held accountable, is at the center of this "yes, and" approach. Corruption isn't an incomprehensible sum that finds itself in the bank account of a distant oligarch. Corruption is a hospital that doesn't have medicine or a road that doesn't get built. Corruption is a food company paying to avoid health inspections, either making people sick or ending up with a recall that limits the supply, making food more expensive for everyone. In recent polling, 81 percent of Americans see "corruption as raising [their] costs personally."
It's easy to see these as separate issues in their extremes: as a goal when people in autocracies are fighting against impossible odds to hold their leaders to account, or when individuals in established democracies are fighting for that "more perfect" part of the union; as a tool when jobs and food are scarce and healthcare is out of reach in democracies and it's time to pick leaders who craft more responsive policies.
Like any goal, it needs to be sought, and like any tool, it needs to be used and maintained. That means policy approaches should aim to improve and consolidate democracy, but also to use it to improve lives while maintaining support for it. It helps that many of the policies that seek the goal of a more democratic world also maintain the tool itself. Improving commitment to the rule of law and rooting out corruption improve people's perception of democracy as a system while also creating a more functioning democracy. A more functional tool leads to better outcomes, as democracy is more responsive and accountable and can lead to better policies.
What We're Doing
How Can the Future of AI Center Human Rights? - As part of our Tech for Good, Tech for Bad initiative, we hosted an event examining how AI can center human rights. I was joined by Sarah Yager from OpenAI and Jason Pielemeier from the Global Network Initiative for the discussion. A major theme of the discussion was the ability to adapt human rights law, principles, and approaches to AI. Sure, there is much that's new about the technology, but human rights has adapted to new technology before, and figuring out what is adaptable versus what is truly novel will be a key issue in centering human rights in AI. Come for the human rights in AI conversation, stay for a truly incredible philosophical point made by Sarah.
Reimagining the Atrocities Prevention Law and Policy Architecture in the U.S. - On October 23, the Alliance for Peacebuilding hosted a full-day conference about the future of atrocity prevention work within the U.S. government. It was a fascinating series of conversations, and one of the main takeaways (which is true for all development work) is that it's not a time to be thinking in predefined boxes, and the realm of the possible is never going to be the same as it was a few years ago, for both better and worse. It's an important time to be reimagining what we can do and how we can do it better, rather than assuming what couldbe. A huge thanks to AfP and Megan Corrado for putting on this event, making sure the community stays together and keeps thinking about what could be.
What I'm Reading (and Watching)
Civic Space is Still Contested, but Not Yet Lost. It's Time for the Big Pivot - Vukasin Petrovic - About a year ago I met with Vukasin, and as we chatted, he posed a fascinating question: What would an offensive civic space look like? For too long, civil society has been on the back foot. Civic space is closing and resources have been stripped away. Authoritarians are emboldened with new tactics in both the online and offline realms. So how does civil society go on the offensive? How can those doing the hard work pivot from defense to offense? This article goes a long way in addressing that question.
Reimagining how the United States advances development in the 21st century: At home and overseas - Ambassador Sarah Mendelson - One of the primary lessons of USAID's dismantling is the immense disconnect between Americans whose primary work is overseas and communities across the U.S. Changing this should be one of the most pressing priorities for any future U.S. development efforts. Ambassador Mendelson (the inaugural director of HRI!) here makes the case for having a "Development Officer Corps" with domestic tours as well as international ones. This could bring needed innovation and cross learning to development efforts, make sure the work is better understood by and ingrained in domestic communities, and help break down the silos that are too common between domestic and foreign affairs. Removing this imaginary barrier is key to a more sustainable future.
Special Bonus (because I haven't read it yet): Education and Conflict in Northeast Nigeria - Dr. Vanita Datta - Alright, alright, alright. I haven't read this one yet, but I got a chance to hear about the research and drafting extensively during the process. Vanita is a good friend and a former colleague, and she just released a book based on her PhD research. Her deep knowledge of what conflict in West Africa means to development outcomes is unmatched, and I have no doubt it comes through here.
We'll be back in December, but until then, keep up with our goings-on on the HRI homepage and on LinkedIn. If you have thoughts or questions, please feel free to reach out at afriedman@csis.org, and if you were forwarded this and enjoyed it, please sign up via the homepage here (https://pardot.csis.org/e/906722/ograms-human-rights-initiative/3tbgqn/4082720440/h/XZlFVEApvbNwNESATpj_F050bBi4ha9s_3JPkz6TRF4).
* * *
Original text here: https://www.csis.org/analysis/human-rights-initiative-directors-note-november-2026-edition
[Category: ThinkTank]
