Think Tanks
Here's a look at documents from think tanks
Think Tanks
Featured Stories
The Buckeye Institute Releases The Buckeye Plan
COLUMBUS, Ohio, Nov. 16 [Category: Think Tank] (TNSrpt) -- The Buckeye Institute, an independent research and educational institution that says its mission is to advance free-market public policy, posted the following news release:
* * *
The Buckeye Institute Releases The Buckeye Plan
*
Columbus, OH - In a press conference Monday morning at the Ohio Statehouse, The Buckeye Institute released its hot-off-the-press booklet: The Buckeye Plan: Powering Ohio's Climb to the Top, which offers 79 specific recommendations and covers economic growth, energy, education, healthcare, public safety, and ... Show Full Article COLUMBUS, Ohio, Nov. 16 [Category: Think Tank] (TNSrpt) -- The Buckeye Institute, an independent research and educational institution that says its mission is to advance free-market public policy, posted the following news release: * * * The Buckeye Institute Releases The Buckeye Plan * Columbus, OH - In a press conference Monday morning at the Ohio Statehouse, The Buckeye Institute released its hot-off-the-press booklet: The Buckeye Plan: Powering Ohio's Climb to the Top, which offers 79 specific recommendations and covers economic growth, energy, education, healthcare, public safety, andgovernment accountability.
"The Buckeye Plan provides sensible ideas for building upon Ohio's recent successes as well as innovative public policy solutions to address ongoing challenges," said Robert Alt, president and chief executive officer of The Buckeye Institute. "We hope the Acton administration and Ohio's next General Assembly will recommit to what has already worked well by continuing to expand economic growth and prosperity to every corner and community of the Buckeye State and reducing government's burden on the lives and businesses of Ohioans."
"With rapidly evolving technology, increased energy demand, and an aging society, Ohio's policymakers face difficult choices," said Rea S. Hederman Jr., executive director of the Economic Research Center and vice president of policy at The Buckeye Institute. "Ohio has taken impressive steps to modernize its economy, cut taxes, reduce regulations, reform education, and ensure affordable, reliable, and abundant energy. The policy agenda outlined in The Buckeye Plan can keep Ohio on track, build upon positive momentum, strengthen our economy, ensure public safety, and provide good jobs."
* * *
REPORT: https://www.buckeyeinstitute.org/library/docLib/2026-11-16-The-Buckeye-Plan-policy-book.pdf
***
Original text here: https://www.buckeyeinstitute.org/research/detail/the-buckeye-institute-releases-the-buckeye-plan
* * *
The Buckeye Institute Releases The Buckeye Plan
*
Columbus, OH - In a press conference Monday morning at the Ohio Statehouse, The Buckeye Institute released its hot-off-the-press booklet: The Buckeye Plan: Powering Ohio's Climb to the Top, which offers 79 specific recommendations and covers economic growth, energy, education, healthcare, public safety, and ... Show Full Article COLUMBUS, Ohio, Nov. 16 [Category: Think Tank] (TNSrpt) -- The Buckeye Institute, an independent research and educational institution that says its mission is to advance free-market public policy, posted the following news release: * * * The Buckeye Institute Releases The Buckeye Plan * Columbus, OH - In a press conference Monday morning at the Ohio Statehouse, The Buckeye Institute released its hot-off-the-press booklet: The Buckeye Plan: Powering Ohio's Climb to the Top, which offers 79 specific recommendations and covers economic growth, energy, education, healthcare, public safety, andgovernment accountability.
"The Buckeye Plan provides sensible ideas for building upon Ohio's recent successes as well as innovative public policy solutions to address ongoing challenges," said Robert Alt, president and chief executive officer of The Buckeye Institute. "We hope the Acton administration and Ohio's next General Assembly will recommit to what has already worked well by continuing to expand economic growth and prosperity to every corner and community of the Buckeye State and reducing government's burden on the lives and businesses of Ohioans."
"With rapidly evolving technology, increased energy demand, and an aging society, Ohio's policymakers face difficult choices," said Rea S. Hederman Jr., executive director of the Economic Research Center and vice president of policy at The Buckeye Institute. "Ohio has taken impressive steps to modernize its economy, cut taxes, reduce regulations, reform education, and ensure affordable, reliable, and abundant energy. The policy agenda outlined in The Buckeye Plan can keep Ohio on track, build upon positive momentum, strengthen our economy, ensure public safety, and provide good jobs."
* * *
REPORT: https://www.buckeyeinstitute.org/library/docLib/2026-11-16-The-Buckeye-Plan-policy-book.pdf
***
Original text here: https://www.buckeyeinstitute.org/research/detail/the-buckeye-institute-releases-the-buckeye-plan
Ceres Urges SEC to Preserve Shareholder Proposal Rule That Strengthens Company Value
BOSTON, Massachusetts, Nov. 16 [Category: ThinkTank] -- Ceres, a non-profit organization that is mobilizing companies and investors to take stronger action on climate change, water scarcity and global sustainability challenges, posted the following news release:
* * *
Ceres Urges SEC to Preserve Shareholder Proposal Rule That Strengthens Company Value
*
BOSTON - Ceres urged the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to withdraw a proposal that would rescind an important federal rule shareholders rely on to prompt meaningful dialogue with companies on a range of financial business issues.
The ... Show Full Article BOSTON, Massachusetts, Nov. 16 [Category: ThinkTank] -- Ceres, a non-profit organization that is mobilizing companies and investors to take stronger action on climate change, water scarcity and global sustainability challenges, posted the following news release: * * * Ceres Urges SEC to Preserve Shareholder Proposal Rule That Strengthens Company Value * BOSTON - Ceres urged the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to withdraw a proposal that would rescind an important federal rule shareholders rely on to prompt meaningful dialogue with companies on a range of financial business issues. TheSEC plans to undo Rule 14a-8, the primary means by which shareholders can include written requests in company proxy ballots.
In a public comment letter submitted today, Ceres opposed the rescission, arguing that the SEC would undo the primary way investors make their views on material matters known to the corporate boards and management they own stating:
"If adopted, it would create extraordinary uncertainty about the path forward for shareholders to influence corporate decision-making (and also for companies that think it important to engage with their shareholders); would make it particularly difficult or impossible for retail or small shareholders to make proposals and for others to vote on those proposals; would greatly impede shareholders' ability to drive important good-governance and other goals; would inevitably lead to an increase in litigation regarding what can or cannot go into a company's proxy statement; would prompt investors to take other paths such as "vote no" campaigns or proxy fights; and would have other untoward results."
Ceres' Key Points:
* Proposals act as an early warning system for financial risk. Investors filed 264 proposals asking companies to assess and disclose financial sustainability risks from 2002 through 2024. Companies initially resisted, but over time sustainability reporting became standard practice. By 2025, 94% of S&P 500 companies issued sustainability reports.
* Proposals drive mainstream governance improvements. In 1999, roughly 40% of S&P 500 companies had boards of directors with annual director elections, which are associated with higher firm value. By 2025, 88% of S&P 500 companies had all directors elected annually.
* Rescission affects all investors. Asset managers, pension funds representing teachers, laborers, public safety officials, and others holding trillions of dollars in assets may never file a proposal. But they rely on proxy votes to protect their beneficiaries. Fewer proposals on the ballot would diminish their voice, and the SEC's economic analysis fails to account for them.
The letter also challenges the SEC's position that it lacks authority to issue Rule 14a-8, a rule that has been in place for more than 80 years, challenges its policy rationales for rescission, and claims that shareholder proposals are a costly and unnecessary burden imposed on public companies.
"Shareholder proposals often flag significant financial issues, from those related to extreme weather to transition risk, before they become systemic problems, and they help companies address these issues and strengthen long-term value," said Steven Rothstein, Chief Program Officer at Ceres. "Many of today's responsible business and governance practices we've come to know became mainstream largely because of Rule 14a-8. Rescinding the rule throws away those benefits with little concrete evidence of harm and will make it difficult or impossible for shareholders to bring requests to companies."
Since the SEC announced its intention to rescind Rule 14a-8, a growing number of bipartisan advocates, institutional investors, and faith-based investors have spoken in support of keeping the longstanding rule in place. In a piece in the Washington Examiner, former Florida Republican Congressman Carlos Curbelo said, "A government that decides which investor voices are legitimate and then removes the mechanism for the others to be heard is not reducing regulation. It is substituting political judgment for market discipline." Peter Flaherty, Chairman and CEO of the National Legal and Policy Center, wrote in the Wall Street Journal, "Closing the process doesn't remove politics from markets; it prevents owners from resolving policy disagreements through market mechanisms.
In July, Ceres, the U.S. Sustainable Investment Forum, the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, the Shareholder Rights Group, For the Long Term, and New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli signed a letter petitioning the SEC to pursue a different approach rather than rescinding the rule.
***
Original text here: https://www.ceres.org/resources/news/ceres-urges-sec-to-preserve-shareholder-proposal-rule-that-strengthens-company-value (TNSmlt)
* * *
Ceres Urges SEC to Preserve Shareholder Proposal Rule That Strengthens Company Value
*
BOSTON - Ceres urged the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to withdraw a proposal that would rescind an important federal rule shareholders rely on to prompt meaningful dialogue with companies on a range of financial business issues.
The ... Show Full Article BOSTON, Massachusetts, Nov. 16 [Category: ThinkTank] -- Ceres, a non-profit organization that is mobilizing companies and investors to take stronger action on climate change, water scarcity and global sustainability challenges, posted the following news release: * * * Ceres Urges SEC to Preserve Shareholder Proposal Rule That Strengthens Company Value * BOSTON - Ceres urged the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to withdraw a proposal that would rescind an important federal rule shareholders rely on to prompt meaningful dialogue with companies on a range of financial business issues. TheSEC plans to undo Rule 14a-8, the primary means by which shareholders can include written requests in company proxy ballots.
In a public comment letter submitted today, Ceres opposed the rescission, arguing that the SEC would undo the primary way investors make their views on material matters known to the corporate boards and management they own stating:
"If adopted, it would create extraordinary uncertainty about the path forward for shareholders to influence corporate decision-making (and also for companies that think it important to engage with their shareholders); would make it particularly difficult or impossible for retail or small shareholders to make proposals and for others to vote on those proposals; would greatly impede shareholders' ability to drive important good-governance and other goals; would inevitably lead to an increase in litigation regarding what can or cannot go into a company's proxy statement; would prompt investors to take other paths such as "vote no" campaigns or proxy fights; and would have other untoward results."
Ceres' Key Points:
* Proposals act as an early warning system for financial risk. Investors filed 264 proposals asking companies to assess and disclose financial sustainability risks from 2002 through 2024. Companies initially resisted, but over time sustainability reporting became standard practice. By 2025, 94% of S&P 500 companies issued sustainability reports.
* Proposals drive mainstream governance improvements. In 1999, roughly 40% of S&P 500 companies had boards of directors with annual director elections, which are associated with higher firm value. By 2025, 88% of S&P 500 companies had all directors elected annually.
* Rescission affects all investors. Asset managers, pension funds representing teachers, laborers, public safety officials, and others holding trillions of dollars in assets may never file a proposal. But they rely on proxy votes to protect their beneficiaries. Fewer proposals on the ballot would diminish their voice, and the SEC's economic analysis fails to account for them.
The letter also challenges the SEC's position that it lacks authority to issue Rule 14a-8, a rule that has been in place for more than 80 years, challenges its policy rationales for rescission, and claims that shareholder proposals are a costly and unnecessary burden imposed on public companies.
"Shareholder proposals often flag significant financial issues, from those related to extreme weather to transition risk, before they become systemic problems, and they help companies address these issues and strengthen long-term value," said Steven Rothstein, Chief Program Officer at Ceres. "Many of today's responsible business and governance practices we've come to know became mainstream largely because of Rule 14a-8. Rescinding the rule throws away those benefits with little concrete evidence of harm and will make it difficult or impossible for shareholders to bring requests to companies."
Since the SEC announced its intention to rescind Rule 14a-8, a growing number of bipartisan advocates, institutional investors, and faith-based investors have spoken in support of keeping the longstanding rule in place. In a piece in the Washington Examiner, former Florida Republican Congressman Carlos Curbelo said, "A government that decides which investor voices are legitimate and then removes the mechanism for the others to be heard is not reducing regulation. It is substituting political judgment for market discipline." Peter Flaherty, Chairman and CEO of the National Legal and Policy Center, wrote in the Wall Street Journal, "Closing the process doesn't remove politics from markets; it prevents owners from resolving policy disagreements through market mechanisms.
In July, Ceres, the U.S. Sustainable Investment Forum, the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, the Shareholder Rights Group, For the Long Term, and New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli signed a letter petitioning the SEC to pursue a different approach rather than rescinding the rule.
***
Original text here: https://www.ceres.org/resources/news/ceres-urges-sec-to-preserve-shareholder-proposal-rule-that-strengthens-company-value (TNSmlt)
Barry Goldwater Saw a Way Out of the Wilderness
PHOENIX, Arizona, Nov. 16 [Category: ThinkTank] -- The Goldwater Institute posted the following news:
* * *
Barry Goldwater Saw a Way Out of the Wilderness
*
Barry Goldwater was acquainted with political setbacks. The morning after the 1964 presidential election, he could count the states he had won on two hands. Harder to number were the Americans who had spent that fall knocking on doors for the first time because a senator from Arizona had given voice to something they believed. Goldwater had asked them to help Americans reclaim power from Washington.
After the loss, Goldwater urged his ... Show Full Article PHOENIX, Arizona, Nov. 16 [Category: ThinkTank] -- The Goldwater Institute posted the following news: * * * Barry Goldwater Saw a Way Out of the Wilderness * Barry Goldwater was acquainted with political setbacks. The morning after the 1964 presidential election, he could count the states he had won on two hands. Harder to number were the Americans who had spent that fall knocking on doors for the first time because a senator from Arizona had given voice to something they believed. Goldwater had asked them to help Americans reclaim power from Washington. After the loss, Goldwater urged hissupporters not to give up the fight for free markets, smaller government, and the American family. It was the collective conviction that Americans could build better lives for their families if they could keep more of what they earned and decide for themselves how to raise their children that kept these people invested in American politics.
In the years that followed, Goldwater's volunteers organized their precincts, recruited candidates, and proposed the conservative platform to their neighbors. Some ran for office themselves. Chief among these Goldwater successors was Ronald Reagan. In 1966, Californians elected Reagan governor. Fourteen years later, Americans sent him and their shared beliefs to the White House.
Those who believe in liberty have reason to remember the history of Goldwater and the conservative movement's time in the wilderness as they take stock of November's election. Whatever happens in Washington, there's still work to be done locally. A city council can change a zoning rule to put a starter home within reach of a young family, and state lawmakers can give parents more say over where their children go to school. Elections come and go, but conservative principles remain.
In that spirit, the will join the 1912 Institute and other partners on November 16 to host FreeCon Phoenix. The sold-out gathering is the first of a series where advocates of liberty will consider how their ideas can improve Americans' lives. The discussion in Phoenix will take up a question Barry Goldwater would have recognized: How do we make the case for freedom and limited government to those who do not see that light?
Other FreeCon gatherings will follow in Philadelphia (hosted by National Review and the Commonwealth Foundation), Washington, D.C., and Raleigh, N.C.
Phoenix is a fitting place to start these conversations: The state of Arizona has shown that freedom makes life better for everyone. In 2011, Arizona became the first state to offer education savings accounts. Initially offered for parents raising a child with a disability, it meant being able to put some of the money toward tuition and save enough for the reading tutor their child needed. Arizona later opened the program to every child eligible for public school.
Arizonans also applied these same conservative principles to the right to build a home and earn a living. Under Arizona's Permit Freedom Act -- developed by the Goldwater Institute -- a family applying for a building permit can find out what construction regulations require and the obligations the city is required to uphold in regard to the construction. The institute also helped Arizona recognize occupational licenses earned in other states. A tradesman who moves here can use the credentials he's already earned to qualify for a license and begin working again. Over two dozen states have now adopted these kinds of reforms, improving the lives of students, workers, and builders all over the country at the local and state levels of politics, proving that freedom benefits everyone.
Barry Goldwater understood something about the view from the wilderness. From the vantage point of Arizona, he understood how much of the potential of American life lay beyond the boundaries of Washington and how much citizens who support individual liberty could accomplish in the proverbial wilds, even after a bruising defeat. That's the lesson we look forward to discussing with old friends and newcomers at FreeCon Phoenix.
Some will arrive at the conference with an idea that has already made life better for their neighbors. Others will come looking for an answer to a problem their community has faced for years. We're glad they'll have the chance to meet in Goldwater's hometown to begin forging a path out of the wilderness to a future of individual liberty where everyday Americans are free to live their lives without interference from Washington bureaucrats.
Victor Riches is the President and CEO of the Goldwater Institute, leading the Institute's efforts to help people in all 50 states live freer, happier lives.
Since 1988, the Goldwater Institute has been in the liberty business -- defending and promoting freedom, and achieving more than 400 victories in all 50 states. Donate today to help support our mission.
We Protect Your Rights
Our attorneys defend individual rights and protect those who cannot protect themselves.
Sign up for the latest news, event updates, and more.
Wait! Don't close this yet!
We are grateful for your support of the Goldwater Institute's efforts to advance and defend liberty throughout the United States. For over 36 years, we've been defending the rights of Americans to live their lives free from government interference.
And Goldwater is unique in that we direct our efforts to the 50 states where we introduce and advance innovative ideas that expand freedom. And we fight in courtrooms and capitals nationwide to defend individual liberty.
In 2024 alone, we scored over 50 policy and litigation victories defending liberty!
And that's just the beginning.
Our plans for 2025 include:
Stopping pernicious DEI and other woke programs in America's universities.
Ensuring that patients suffering from rare and terminal diseases have access to cutting-edge, lifesaving medical treatments, without having to first seek permission from the government.
Defending parental rights across the United States so that parents can send their kids to the school that best fits their needs, free from leftist indoctrination.
Eliminating government interference in the fundamental right of individuals to own property and use it as they see fit.
And much, much more
We seek to restore the presumption of liberty; that people are free to act without first asking permission from the government.
But we cannot do this without you. Will you join us as we fight to preserve and advance liberty throughout the country? As we seek new and innovative ways to defend freedom in all 50 states?
And there's great news: Thanks to a generous Goldwater supporter, your donation today will be doubled!
So please, join us in fighting to advance liberty and score real wins for freedom from coast to coast!
***
Original text here: https://www.goldwaterinstitute.org/barry-goldwater-saw-a-way-out-of-the-wilderness/
* * *
Barry Goldwater Saw a Way Out of the Wilderness
*
Barry Goldwater was acquainted with political setbacks. The morning after the 1964 presidential election, he could count the states he had won on two hands. Harder to number were the Americans who had spent that fall knocking on doors for the first time because a senator from Arizona had given voice to something they believed. Goldwater had asked them to help Americans reclaim power from Washington.
After the loss, Goldwater urged his ... Show Full Article PHOENIX, Arizona, Nov. 16 [Category: ThinkTank] -- The Goldwater Institute posted the following news: * * * Barry Goldwater Saw a Way Out of the Wilderness * Barry Goldwater was acquainted with political setbacks. The morning after the 1964 presidential election, he could count the states he had won on two hands. Harder to number were the Americans who had spent that fall knocking on doors for the first time because a senator from Arizona had given voice to something they believed. Goldwater had asked them to help Americans reclaim power from Washington. After the loss, Goldwater urged hissupporters not to give up the fight for free markets, smaller government, and the American family. It was the collective conviction that Americans could build better lives for their families if they could keep more of what they earned and decide for themselves how to raise their children that kept these people invested in American politics.
In the years that followed, Goldwater's volunteers organized their precincts, recruited candidates, and proposed the conservative platform to their neighbors. Some ran for office themselves. Chief among these Goldwater successors was Ronald Reagan. In 1966, Californians elected Reagan governor. Fourteen years later, Americans sent him and their shared beliefs to the White House.
Those who believe in liberty have reason to remember the history of Goldwater and the conservative movement's time in the wilderness as they take stock of November's election. Whatever happens in Washington, there's still work to be done locally. A city council can change a zoning rule to put a starter home within reach of a young family, and state lawmakers can give parents more say over where their children go to school. Elections come and go, but conservative principles remain.
In that spirit, the will join the 1912 Institute and other partners on November 16 to host FreeCon Phoenix. The sold-out gathering is the first of a series where advocates of liberty will consider how their ideas can improve Americans' lives. The discussion in Phoenix will take up a question Barry Goldwater would have recognized: How do we make the case for freedom and limited government to those who do not see that light?
Other FreeCon gatherings will follow in Philadelphia (hosted by National Review and the Commonwealth Foundation), Washington, D.C., and Raleigh, N.C.
Phoenix is a fitting place to start these conversations: The state of Arizona has shown that freedom makes life better for everyone. In 2011, Arizona became the first state to offer education savings accounts. Initially offered for parents raising a child with a disability, it meant being able to put some of the money toward tuition and save enough for the reading tutor their child needed. Arizona later opened the program to every child eligible for public school.
Arizonans also applied these same conservative principles to the right to build a home and earn a living. Under Arizona's Permit Freedom Act -- developed by the Goldwater Institute -- a family applying for a building permit can find out what construction regulations require and the obligations the city is required to uphold in regard to the construction. The institute also helped Arizona recognize occupational licenses earned in other states. A tradesman who moves here can use the credentials he's already earned to qualify for a license and begin working again. Over two dozen states have now adopted these kinds of reforms, improving the lives of students, workers, and builders all over the country at the local and state levels of politics, proving that freedom benefits everyone.
Barry Goldwater understood something about the view from the wilderness. From the vantage point of Arizona, he understood how much of the potential of American life lay beyond the boundaries of Washington and how much citizens who support individual liberty could accomplish in the proverbial wilds, even after a bruising defeat. That's the lesson we look forward to discussing with old friends and newcomers at FreeCon Phoenix.
Some will arrive at the conference with an idea that has already made life better for their neighbors. Others will come looking for an answer to a problem their community has faced for years. We're glad they'll have the chance to meet in Goldwater's hometown to begin forging a path out of the wilderness to a future of individual liberty where everyday Americans are free to live their lives without interference from Washington bureaucrats.
Victor Riches is the President and CEO of the Goldwater Institute, leading the Institute's efforts to help people in all 50 states live freer, happier lives.
Since 1988, the Goldwater Institute has been in the liberty business -- defending and promoting freedom, and achieving more than 400 victories in all 50 states. Donate today to help support our mission.
We Protect Your Rights
Our attorneys defend individual rights and protect those who cannot protect themselves.
Sign up for the latest news, event updates, and more.
Wait! Don't close this yet!
We are grateful for your support of the Goldwater Institute's efforts to advance and defend liberty throughout the United States. For over 36 years, we've been defending the rights of Americans to live their lives free from government interference.
And Goldwater is unique in that we direct our efforts to the 50 states where we introduce and advance innovative ideas that expand freedom. And we fight in courtrooms and capitals nationwide to defend individual liberty.
In 2024 alone, we scored over 50 policy and litigation victories defending liberty!
And that's just the beginning.
Our plans for 2025 include:
Stopping pernicious DEI and other woke programs in America's universities.
Ensuring that patients suffering from rare and terminal diseases have access to cutting-edge, lifesaving medical treatments, without having to first seek permission from the government.
Defending parental rights across the United States so that parents can send their kids to the school that best fits their needs, free from leftist indoctrination.
Eliminating government interference in the fundamental right of individuals to own property and use it as they see fit.
And much, much more
We seek to restore the presumption of liberty; that people are free to act without first asking permission from the government.
But we cannot do this without you. Will you join us as we fight to preserve and advance liberty throughout the country? As we seek new and innovative ways to defend freedom in all 50 states?
And there's great news: Thanks to a generous Goldwater supporter, your donation today will be doubled!
So please, join us in fighting to advance liberty and score real wins for freedom from coast to coast!
***
Original text here: https://www.goldwaterinstitute.org/barry-goldwater-saw-a-way-out-of-the-wilderness/
Resources for the Future: Where Does the Marginal Methane Molecule Come From? Implications of LNG Exports for US Natural Gas Supply and Methane Emissions
WASHINGTON, Nov. 15 (TNSLrpt) -- Resources for the Future issued the following working paper on November 11, 2026, entitled "Where Does the Marginal Methane Molecule Come From? Implications of LNG Exports for US Natural Gas Supply and Methane Emissions".
Here are excerpts:
* * *
Abstract
US exports of liquefied natural gas have surged over the past decade and are projected to more than double again by 2030 as more capacity is built. This has raised concerns about upward pressure on domestic energy prices as well as increased methane emissions from expanded oil and gas production. The magnitude ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 15 (TNSLrpt) -- Resources for the Future issued the following working paper on November 11, 2026, entitled "Where Does the Marginal Methane Molecule Come From? Implications of LNG Exports for US Natural Gas Supply and Methane Emissions". Here are excerpts: * * * Abstract US exports of liquefied natural gas have surged over the past decade and are projected to more than double again by 2030 as more capacity is built. This has raised concerns about upward pressure on domestic energy prices as well as increased methane emissions from expanded oil and gas production. The magnitudeof potential increases in natural gas prices depends on how much US supply is anticipated to respond, and impacts on methane emissions will depend on which oil and gas basins that supply will come from because methane leak rates vary dramatically across basins.
Using a dataset on more than 1 million US oil and gas wells, I model the spatially heterogeneous supply responses to US export demand for both US natural gas and crude oil to estimate the impacts on domestic energy prices and the effective methane leak rates of marginal supply. Gas export demand mostly spurs marginal gas supply from Appalachia where methane leak rates are low, yielding effective methane leak rates more than 40% below the national average. Oil export demand mostly spurs production from the Permian Basin with effective leak rates nearly 3 times the national average.
A gas export demand shock equivalent to roughly 1% of US supply drives larger gas price effects (+2.4% per billion cubic feet/day) than estimated in other studies, while oil export demand of similar magnitude has smaller impacts on oil prices (+0.9% per 100k barrels/day).
* * *
View full working paper at: https://www.rff.org/publications/working-papers/where-does-the-marginal-methane-molecule-come-from-implications-of-lng-exports-for-us-natural-gas-supply-and-methane-emissions/
[Category: ThinkTank]
Here are excerpts:
* * *
Abstract
US exports of liquefied natural gas have surged over the past decade and are projected to more than double again by 2030 as more capacity is built. This has raised concerns about upward pressure on domestic energy prices as well as increased methane emissions from expanded oil and gas production. The magnitude ... Show Full Article WASHINGTON, Nov. 15 (TNSLrpt) -- Resources for the Future issued the following working paper on November 11, 2026, entitled "Where Does the Marginal Methane Molecule Come From? Implications of LNG Exports for US Natural Gas Supply and Methane Emissions". Here are excerpts: * * * Abstract US exports of liquefied natural gas have surged over the past decade and are projected to more than double again by 2030 as more capacity is built. This has raised concerns about upward pressure on domestic energy prices as well as increased methane emissions from expanded oil and gas production. The magnitudeof potential increases in natural gas prices depends on how much US supply is anticipated to respond, and impacts on methane emissions will depend on which oil and gas basins that supply will come from because methane leak rates vary dramatically across basins.
Using a dataset on more than 1 million US oil and gas wells, I model the spatially heterogeneous supply responses to US export demand for both US natural gas and crude oil to estimate the impacts on domestic energy prices and the effective methane leak rates of marginal supply. Gas export demand mostly spurs marginal gas supply from Appalachia where methane leak rates are low, yielding effective methane leak rates more than 40% below the national average. Oil export demand mostly spurs production from the Permian Basin with effective leak rates nearly 3 times the national average.
A gas export demand shock equivalent to roughly 1% of US supply drives larger gas price effects (+2.4% per billion cubic feet/day) than estimated in other studies, while oil export demand of similar magnitude has smaller impacts on oil prices (+0.9% per 100k barrels/day).
* * *
View full working paper at: https://www.rff.org/publications/working-papers/where-does-the-marginal-methane-molecule-come-from-implications-of-lng-exports-for-us-natural-gas-supply-and-methane-emissions/
[Category: ThinkTank]
Institute for Energy Economics & Financial Analysis: 'Emerging Trends, Policy Signals and Pathways for Credible Carbon Pricing'
LAKEWOOD, Ohio, Nov. 15 (TNSLrpt) -- The Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis issued the following report on November 12, 2026, entitled "Emerging trends, policy signals and pathways for credible carbon pricing."
Here are excerpts:
* * *
The Global Green Growth Institute (GGGI), the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) and the Southeast Asia Energy Transition Partnership (UNOPS-ETP) have jointly developed this policy paper with the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP). The paper draws on reviews of China, Japan, ... Show Full Article LAKEWOOD, Ohio, Nov. 15 (TNSLrpt) -- The Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis issued the following report on November 12, 2026, entitled "Emerging trends, policy signals and pathways for credible carbon pricing." Here are excerpts: * * * The Global Green Growth Institute (GGGI), the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) and the Southeast Asia Energy Transition Partnership (UNOPS-ETP) have jointly developed this policy paper with the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP). The paper draws on reviews of China, Japan,the Republic of Korea, Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines and Vietnam, and it studies the history of carbon policy development and the likely future market development based on current policy trajectories.
The paper sets out shared solutions for East and Southeast Asian economies and offers policies suited to the region's political economy, including higher carbon prices and flexible cap design. In addition, it analyses the effects of the European Union (EU) Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and explores how governments can build demand for high-integrity carbon credits. Country findings were tested through workshops and consultations with government officials, regulators, exchange and registry operators, utilities, industry, financial institutions, developers and researchers. Responses and feedback were used to shape final recommendations and ground them in the national context. Further, research and recommendations were shaped by the review of GGGI's carbon finance experts and the Expert Working Group (EWG) - an international group of leading experts on carbon markets and economics convened by GGGI to share best practice from across the globe. EWG members attended consultation workshops and provided direct review of the policy paper chapters. Finally, findings and recommendations were shaped by dialogues amongst high-level policymakers, industry leaders and sector practitioners at the World Economic Forum Decarbonization and Circularity for Industrial Growth and Competitiveness Dialogue, the 2026 Asia Carbon Pricing Forum and the 16th Asia-Pacific Carbon Markets Roundtable, which were supported by GGGI. The policy paper's findings will inform the Diagnostic and Roadmap reports in 2027.
Emissions trading system design and implementation
Carbon prices, emissions coverage and institutional capacity influence how emissions trading systems (ETS) function. In several of the analyzed Asian systems, low prices, generous free allocation and allowance oversupply create constraints. These experiences provide a basis for examining how allocation rules, cap design, market participation and governance affect implementation. In addition, the implications for investment and power-sector decarbonization are also considered, recognizing that outcomes depend on market conditions and complementary policies.
Insights from the experiences of China, Japan and Republic of Korea
Southeast Asian economies face distinct implementation challenges as they establish compliance mechanisms. Early regional experience illustrates the difficulties of developing trading liquidity, transparent pricing and robust governance arrangements after launch. Across the region, measurement, reporting and verification (MRV), institutional coordination and credible compliance systems remain critical areas of market development.
The experience of China, Japan and the Republic of Korea (CJK) can inform the choice of emission trading system features, while taking account of the differences in economic structures, regulatory capacity and policy priorities.
* * *
View full report at: https://ieefa.org/resources/emerging-trends-policy-signals-and-pathways-credible-carbon-pricing
[Category: ThinkTank]
Here are excerpts:
* * *
The Global Green Growth Institute (GGGI), the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) and the Southeast Asia Energy Transition Partnership (UNOPS-ETP) have jointly developed this policy paper with the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP). The paper draws on reviews of China, Japan, ... Show Full Article LAKEWOOD, Ohio, Nov. 15 (TNSLrpt) -- The Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis issued the following report on November 12, 2026, entitled "Emerging trends, policy signals and pathways for credible carbon pricing." Here are excerpts: * * * The Global Green Growth Institute (GGGI), the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) and the Southeast Asia Energy Transition Partnership (UNOPS-ETP) have jointly developed this policy paper with the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP). The paper draws on reviews of China, Japan,the Republic of Korea, Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines and Vietnam, and it studies the history of carbon policy development and the likely future market development based on current policy trajectories.
The paper sets out shared solutions for East and Southeast Asian economies and offers policies suited to the region's political economy, including higher carbon prices and flexible cap design. In addition, it analyses the effects of the European Union (EU) Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and explores how governments can build demand for high-integrity carbon credits. Country findings were tested through workshops and consultations with government officials, regulators, exchange and registry operators, utilities, industry, financial institutions, developers and researchers. Responses and feedback were used to shape final recommendations and ground them in the national context. Further, research and recommendations were shaped by the review of GGGI's carbon finance experts and the Expert Working Group (EWG) - an international group of leading experts on carbon markets and economics convened by GGGI to share best practice from across the globe. EWG members attended consultation workshops and provided direct review of the policy paper chapters. Finally, findings and recommendations were shaped by dialogues amongst high-level policymakers, industry leaders and sector practitioners at the World Economic Forum Decarbonization and Circularity for Industrial Growth and Competitiveness Dialogue, the 2026 Asia Carbon Pricing Forum and the 16th Asia-Pacific Carbon Markets Roundtable, which were supported by GGGI. The policy paper's findings will inform the Diagnostic and Roadmap reports in 2027.
Emissions trading system design and implementation
Carbon prices, emissions coverage and institutional capacity influence how emissions trading systems (ETS) function. In several of the analyzed Asian systems, low prices, generous free allocation and allowance oversupply create constraints. These experiences provide a basis for examining how allocation rules, cap design, market participation and governance affect implementation. In addition, the implications for investment and power-sector decarbonization are also considered, recognizing that outcomes depend on market conditions and complementary policies.
Insights from the experiences of China, Japan and Republic of Korea
Southeast Asian economies face distinct implementation challenges as they establish compliance mechanisms. Early regional experience illustrates the difficulties of developing trading liquidity, transparent pricing and robust governance arrangements after launch. Across the region, measurement, reporting and verification (MRV), institutional coordination and credible compliance systems remain critical areas of market development.
The experience of China, Japan and the Republic of Korea (CJK) can inform the choice of emission trading system features, while taking account of the differences in economic structures, regulatory capacity and policy priorities.
* * *
View full report at: https://ieefa.org/resources/emerging-trends-policy-signals-and-pathways-credible-carbon-pricing
[Category: ThinkTank]
Center of the American Experiment Issues Commentary: MN Nuclear Energy Study - RFI Response #2
MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 15 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary:
* * *
MN nuclear energy study: RFI response #2
Written by Darren Nelson
November 14, 2026
This is a copy of my second response, on behalf of American Experiment, to the Request for Information (RFI) from the public by the Great Plains Institute (GPI) regarding the Minnesota Nuclear Energy Study (MNES). The study began on July 1, 2026 and ends by January 30, 2027.
GPI have been contracted to undertake this ... Show Full Article MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 15 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary: * * * MN nuclear energy study: RFI response #2 Written by Darren Nelson November 14, 2026 This is a copy of my second response, on behalf of American Experiment, to the Request for Information (RFI) from the public by the Great Plains Institute (GPI) regarding the Minnesota Nuclear Energy Study (MNES). The study began on July 1, 2026 and ends by January 30, 2027. GPI have been contracted to undertake thisstudy by the Minnesota Department of Commerce at the direction of the Minnesota Legislature under HF 2438. Regarding the RFI, the GPI MNES website states the following:
* The formal Request for Information [RFI] period, open from August 14, 2026, through September 14, 2026, has ended. Submissions of relevant information may still be submitted until November 16, 2026 using the online form linked below. After November 16, no new information will be able to be submitted through the online form.
This second response or submission is in addition to my first one from September 14, 2026. Both are structured according to GPI's 32 guiding questions and 13 topic headings as follows:
* Federal licensing => Q1
* Technology and costs => Q2 to Q8
* Small modular reactors and other advanced technologies => Q9
* Siting and infrastructure => Q10 to Q16
* Nuclear waste => Q17 to Q20
* Host community economic impacts => Q21
* Public safety and emergency planning => Q22
* Minnesota energy and climate goals => Q23
* Development timelines => Q24
* Minnesota laws and regulations => Q25
* Replacement of retiring generation => Q26
* Workforce and training => Q27 to Q29
* Additional Information => Q30 to Q32
Federal licensing
1. How might recent or anticipated changes in federal regulations governing the licensing of nuclear-powered facilities affect the review and approval of such facilities? Please identify any specific regulatory changes, expected effects on licensing timelines, and any supporting sources.
No further comment.
Technology and costs
2. What technological advances have been made with respect to conventional nuclear-powered facilities that affect safety and cost? Please identify specific technology advances and how they impact safety and/or cost.
No further comment.
3. What information should the study consider when evaluating the full lifecycle costs of nuclear generation compared with alternative baseload resource options? Please identify any relevant information regarding capital costs, financing costs, construction risks, cost and schedule overruns, operating and maintenance costs, decommissioning costs, waste management costs, long-term liability exposure, historical experience from comparable projects in the United States or internationally, and other relevant costs or risks.
Chart 1 below shows a comprehensive Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE), where nuclear generation at $37.18 per MWh is less expensive by:
* 1.3x times combined cycle at $50.03;
* 2.4x times than coal at $89.79;
* 3.1x times than natural gas at $115.83;
* 7.9x times than wind at $296.97; and
* 13.3x times than solar at $496.16.
[View chart in the link at bottom]
4. What information should the study consider when evaluating the full life costs of alternative baseload resource options, and why? Please identify relevant technologies and information regarding capital costs, financing costs, construction risks, cost and schedule overruns, operating and maintenance costs, decommissioning costs, waste management costs, long-term liability exposure, historical experience from comparable projects in the United States or internationally, and other relevant costs or risks.
It is important to note that: nuclear power is the best when it comes to total life cycle CO2; plus wind and solar are not without environmental costs, as documented by American Experiment in Shattered Green Dreams. Highlights from this landmark report include:
* A wide variety and large quantity of minerals are used in solar panels, wind turbines, battery storage, transmission lines, and more. The US currently sources most of its minerals from foreign countries that do not adhere to modern environmental or worker health and safety standards.
* The low electricity density of wind and solar generation means that they require at least 10 times as much land per unit of power produced as coal or natural gas-fired power plants. If the US were powered entirely by wind turbines, the land area necessary would exceed two Californias.
* Some components in wind turbines and solar panels are hazardous. Current recycling pathways are uneconomic and underutilized, which means that decommissioned wind turbines and solar panels often end up in landfills.
* The operating lifespan of wind turbines and solar panels is between 20 and 25 years at maximum, while natural gas plants may operate for 40 years, and nuclear plants operate between 40 and 80 years. Decommissioning and repowering wind and solar energy is required more often than other forms of electricity generation, compounding costs.
5. What evidence from nuclear projects developed in the United States or internationally should inform the study's analysis of costs, construction risks, and project performance? Please provide project names, data, reports, or other sources when possible.
No further comment.
6. What information should the study consider when evaluating how the development of new nuclear generation could affect Minnesota ratepayers and electricity rates? You may address effects on electricity rates, construction cost and schedule overruns unrelated to unique events, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, how financial risks could be allocated between ratepayers, utilities, developers, investors, or other parties, and approaches that could protect ratepayers from financial risk.
The Averch-Johnson (A-J) Effect is a well-known concept in economic regulation of a strong tendency, by public utilities and their regulators, towards "gold plating" of the capital base.
Economics Professor Kenneth Train of UC Berkeley wrote a book chapter on The Averch-Johnson Model of Rate-of-Return Regulation in 1991, that had the following observation:
* Averch and Johnson (1962) initiated one of the earliest and most influential investigations into the effects of regulation on the behavior of a regulated firm. They argue that the most prevalent form of regulation currently applied to public utilities, rate-of-return regulation, induces the firm to engage in inefficiencies. These inefficiencies are the natural result of the regulation. Furthermore, the aspects of monopoly control that regulation is intended to address, such as high prices, are not necessarily mitigated, and could be made worse, by the regulation.
The Federal Reserve published a paper by two of their economists in 1987 entitled A Test of Two Views of the Regulatory Mechanism: Averch-Johnson and Joskow. Highlights include:
* Electric utility regulators attempt to maintain a competitive price for electricity by adjusting the rate of return on a utility's capital. However, there are potentially serious problems with this type of regulation related to consumer reactions to price increases and to the types of incentives given to utilities. First, price increases may lower the consumption of electricity, which may reduce earned rates of return below "fair" rates and trigger a price increase, which in turn may lower consumption and trigger another price increase, and so on. Second, utilities may be able to effect price increases by using "too much" capital, that is, by overcapitalizing, which inflates their rate base. Finally, the ability to pass along operating cost increases that originated from productivity declines suggests that utilities may not have the incentive to raise productivity.
Professors Paul Joskow and Richard Schmalensee's addressed the A-J Effect in their 2024 book chapter on Cost of Service Regulation of Electricity Distribution Services in the US:
* In our view, the most important intellectual contribution of the Averch-Johnson paper is not the capital bias result, but rather that it got economists thinking about the implications of various regulatory mechanisms for the regulated firm's costs. In the end, we believe that traditional COSR [cost of service or rate of return regulation] of legal monopolies does lead to inefficiencies, mainly for all of the reasons articulated in the incentive regulation literature.
7. What public subsidies, tax expenditures, financial incentives, or financing mechanisms could apply to new nuclear investments in Minnesota?
The PUC system of electricity revenues and rates setting has been biased in favor of inflating the capital base throughout the 20th century, but has been biased in favor of doing so through wind and solar renewables throughout the 21st century.
Both the capital bias and the renewables bias will probably require legislative reform, but in the meantime the PUC can learn from, and look to apply, incentive regulation. Professors Joskow and Schmalensee of MIT discuss incentive regulation at length:
* There is by now a very extensive and mature theoretical literature on incentive regulation of legal monopolies. Incentive regulation mechanisms have been applied for many years to the regulation of electric utilities in countries other than the US, including Great Britain, New Zealand, Australia, and Canada. Incentive regulation mechanisms of some type have now been introduced into the electricity distribution regulatory process in a majority of US states. These initiatives are never called "incentive regulation" by regulators and policy makers in the US. The policy phrases used routinely now are "performance-based regulation" (PBR) or "alternative regulatory mechanisms" (ARM).
* RPI-X regulation (sometimes called price-cap regulation) [was originally applied] to the newly privatized British Telecom beginning in 1983 and thereafter to all regulated [public utilities] in the UK. Under this system the rate of growth of a weighted average of the regulated firm's prices is constrained not to exceed the rate of growth of the RPI (retail price index) minus X [the opex and capex efficiency factor], set after negotiation by the regulator. It was initially hoped that once X had been set, this system could simply run until competition made regulation redundant, but that did not happen.
The Australian public utilities regulator for the state of New South Wales, IPART, wrote about Incentives for cost saving in CPI-X regimes in July 2011. Highlights from that paper include:
* CPI-X regulation involves setting a price-path (price-cap regulation) for a utility, allowing for changes in inflation (the CPI factor) and expected efficiency improvements (the 'X' factor).
* The 'X' factor may incorporate other aspects in addition to the expected improvement in efficiency, such as rewards for improvements in output quality, service levels or demand management actions.
* Regulators generally aim to set prices/revenues along a path that will generate sufficient revenue to recover the efficient levels of opex and capex, with a reasonable after-tax return on capital.
* The inherent incentives for cost or efficiency savings in the standard CPI-X regime...arise principally because the regime disconnects prices from cost movements after the price path has been set in relation to forecast costs for the period in question.
* This delinking of costs from prices creates an incentive for the regulated firm to cut costs early in a determination period because it retains those cost savings until they are passed through to consumers in lower prices.
* The delinking also creates a counter-incentive to delay until the start of the next determination period any cost savings that would have been done later in the current determination period.
* To preserve the strength of the incentive throughout a determination or control period, both Ofwat and the AER use a carryover mechanism. This mechanism allows utilities to retain, for a period of time at least equal to the length of the control period, the cost-savings that result from improvements in efficiency.
* Ofgem decided to no longer distinguish between opex and capex for the purpose of calculating required revenue. Instead, it treats all expenditure as 'totex' and allocates 85% of it to be recouped from depreciation and a return on capital.
8. How might these measures affect project feasibility, ratepayers, taxpayers, developers, or other parties?
Senator Amy Klobuchar has a web page devoted to Competition Policy that states: "Strong competition policy is necessary to build a vibrant economy that works for consumers, for workers, for entrepreneurs, for local communities, and for companies, large and small." I wrote about Australia's public utilities related Competition Policy in October 2026:
* Market competition is a means to an end. That end is greater freedom to choose, for consumers and suppliers. The main obstacle to that is government. That includes so called 'natural' monopolies and 'public' utilities.
* Australia tested how 'natural' and 'public' these really were, between 1995 and 2005, through National Competition Policy (NCP).
* NCP reforms involved the following: removing anti-competitive regulation and legislation; separating the non-monopoly from the monopoly parts of large state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and government-sponsored enterprises; ensuring competitive neutrality for non-monopoly SOEs; formalizing oversight of pricing for monopoly SOEs, and using incentive regulation; creating a third-party access regime for monopoly infrastructure, whether SOE or not; extending antitrust laws to all SOEs; and having states and territories apply these reforms to local government.
* NCP was directly applied to the following infrastructure industries: electricity (federal and state); natural gas (state); roads (federal, state, and local); and water and sewage (federal, state, and local). It was also designed to indirectly target airports (federal and local), ports (state), postal (federal), rail (federal and state), and telecommunications (federal).
* Policymakers implemented NCP through three agreements between the federal, state, and territorial governments. Annual performance-based payments were provided to the states for nine years, some of which the state of Queensland passed on to local governments for five years to incentivize NCP reform at that level.
* A small 'guide-and-watch dog' called the National Competition Council (NCC) was established to assess progress and make payments on an annual basis.
* Cost-benefit analyses were embedded in every aspect of NCP, including in three major assessments of the economic impacts in 1995, 1999, and 2005. The 2005 assessment found there was a massive net-benefit (benefits over costs) from NCP, i.e. competition performance above competition payments.
* The sowing of $5.5 Billion in taxpayer payments during the NCP decade conservatively reaped more than $1 Trillion in additional benefits for Australians, gained "from productivity and price reductions observed over the 1990s in the electricity, gas, urban water, telecommunications, urban transport, ports and rail freight sectors." This economic return was of Biblical proportions, well over a hundred-fold!
Small modular reactors and other advanced technologies
9. What should the study consider when evaluating the prospects for small modular reactors and factory-built portable modules with a capacity of up to 300 megawatts?Please address any of the following: technologies that are currently available or under development; current federal licensing status; estimated capital, operating, and lifecycle costs; commercial readiness, potential applications in Minnesota; key uncertainties or barriers; relevant projects, studies, or data.
No further comment.
Siting and infrastructure
10. How could the need for water resources for cooling affect where new nuclear facilities could be located in Minnesota? Please identify the cooling needs of different nuclear technologies; the extent to which water requirements could restrict possible locations; potentially suitable locations or types of locations in Minnesota; and the environmental, ecological, climate, or competing-use considerations associated with water use.
No further comment.
11. What is the potential for colocating new nuclear facilities with businesses or facilities that use very large amounts of electricity?
No further comment.
12. What are the environmental and public health impacts of new nuclear facilities? Please identify impacts during construction, operation, decommissioning, and waste management, including potential effects on nearby residents.
According to the US Department of Energy, under President Joe Biden, on March 31, 2021 there are 3 Reasons Why Nuclear is Clean and Sustainable:
* Nuclear energy protects air quality.
* Nuclear energy's land footprint is small.
* Nuclear energy produces minimal waste.
* Nuclear is a zero-emission clean energy source. It also keeps the air clean by removing thousands of tons of harmful air pollutants each year that contribute to acid rain, smog, lung cancer and cardiovascular disease. The US avoided more than 471 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions in 2020. That's the equivalent of removing 100 million cars from the road and more than all other clean energy sources combined.
* A typical 1,000-megawatt nuclear facility in the US needs a little more than 1 square mile to operate. Wind farms require 360 times more land area to produce the same amount of electricity and solar photovoltaic plants require 75 times more space. To put that in perspective, you would need more than 3 million solar panels to produce the same amount of power as a typical commercial reactor or more than 430 wind turbines (capacity factor not included).
* All of the used nuclear fuel produced by the US nuclear energy industry over the last 60 years could fit on a football field at a depth of less than 10 yards! That waste can also be reprocessed and recycled, although the US does not currently do this. However, some advanced reactor designs being developed could operate on used fuel.
13. What information should the study consider that would inform the prospects for acceptance of new nuclear facilities by host communities?
See my comments below for Q15.
14. What factors could affect whether a host community would support or oppose a new nuclear facility?
See my comments below for Q15.
15. What best practices should be used to engage potential host communities and nearby residents regarding new nuclear facilities? Please consider when engagement should begin, who should be included, what information should be available, and how community input should inform decisions.
I believe NIMBYnomics offers some valuable insights for Q13, Q14 and Q15 as follows:
* NIMBY stands for "Not In My back Yard." This is a truly bipartisan phenomenon that helps block all sorts of economic development at the local level, and sometimes state and federal. Blocking nuclear power and family housing are examples of typical Left NIMBYism. Blocking wind and solar power and public housing are examples of typical Right NIMBYism. Blocking data centers is the prime example of combined Left, Right and Center NIMBYism. The key to better understanding and addressing NIMBYism is Public Choice economics.
* One important insight from Public Choice is that there is not just a civilian marketplace but also a political marketplace that both obey the laws of self-interested demand and supply. A second important insight is that democracy is rarely a romantic endeavour but a dirty business where private interests, of the majority or minority, often defeat the public interest. A third important insight is that special interests have greater incentives, of a monetary or psych nature, to be very active in politics. Economists call them "Bootleggers and Baptists."
* The issue of concentrated costs versus diffuse benefits is the economic root of the NIMBY problem. Hindering negotiated compensation solutions to NIMBY problems are transaction costs, or the "costs of engaging in economic calculation" based on market prices and property rights. It is an old saying that "everyone has a price." Institutions can better align rights, costs and benefits to allow developers and NIMBYs to negotiate, and legally pay, a compensation price.
* In politics and policy, special interests often gazump the public interest. NIMBYism is one increasingly common example of this, especially in terms of data centers and nuclear power. NIMBYs are motivated by strong incentives of concentrated costs, monetary and non-monetary. Development advocates are motivated by weaker incentives of dispersed benefits. NIMBY "Bootleggers" can often be bought off at the right compensation price and in the right institutional circumstances. NIMBY "Baptists" sometimes and increasingly cannot.
* Today, Minnesota is sliding into something worse [than NIMBY, "Not In My Backyard"]: BANANA, or "Build Absolutely Nothing Anywhere Near Anything." It's no longer about location. It's about stopping the project, period, no matter where it is, how it's run or how much it benefits Minnesota. - Pat Garofalo, "Minnesota's slide from NIMBY to BANANA" July 20, 2026
16. How could electric transmission capacity, grid interconnection requirements, or related infrastructure affect potential locations and development timelines for new nuclear facilities?
Utility Dive reported on November 10, 2026 that:
* The Senate voted Monday to advance the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a major piece of permitting reform legislation, but some experts and lawmakers have voiced skepticism about its future in the lame duck session following midterm elections in which Democrats handily won control of both chambers of Congress.
* In a research note sent Monday following the vote, Jefferies analysts said the manager's amendment "largely preserves" the bill's original framework "but is incrementally better for transmission, offshore-wind projects, nuclear, and non-RTO utilities, and worse for large BTM gas configurations, incumbent RTO utilities and projects relying on strong permit certainty."
* Former FERC Chairman Mark Christie said in a Monday LinkedIn post that the manager's amendment had not "at all" addressed two of his three major concerns with the legislation. "The 'public interest' standard in the bill remains a blank check for FERC to override the states and order trillions of dollars in new transmission built to fit the policies of a President or more likely, special interest lobbying of RTOs." He added that the legislation doesn't give states authority over cost allocation for large transmission projects "that will cost their consumers tons of money."
* Paul Cicio, CEO of the trade association Industrial Energy Consumers of America and chair of the Electricity Transmission Competition Coalition, criticized the bill in a Monday LinkedIn post, saying it "fails to unleash transmission competition and deliver cost savings to ratepayers." He also said, "without competition, a monopoly utility has zero incentive to reduce costs. Section 2105 codifies existing exceptions to competition that are used by the monopoly utilities to evade competition."
Nuclear waste
17. What information should the study consider regarding the amount and toxicity of radioactive waste produced by conventional nuclear technologies and small modular reactors? Please identify differences among technologies and provide supporting evidence or sources when available.
No further comment.
18. What should the study consider when evaluating the costs, risks, and long-term requirements of storing nuclear waste on-site?
No further comment.
19. What are the prospects for developing a permanent, federally or privately owned repository to which nuclear waste from Minnesota could be transported? Please address relevant technical, regulatory, legal, financial, political, transportation, or timing considerations.
No further comment.
20. What should the study consider when evaluating the feasibility and cost of reprocessing nuclear waste? Please identify potential benefits, risks, limitations, or relevant examples.
No further comment.
Host community economic impacts
21. What economic impacts could different nuclear technologies have on a host community? Please consider employment during construction, long-term employment during operations, local purchases by a nuclear facility and its employees, effects on local businesses and economic activity, tax revenue for local governments and schools, state tax revenue, potential costs to the host community, differences among conventional reactors, small modular reactors, and other advanced technologies.
Both Minnesota Management and Budget (MMB) and the Public Utilities Commission (PUC) should be encouraged to create, sooner rather than later, official guidelines on cost benefit analysis (CBA) and economic impact analysis (EIA).
The MMB website has a webpage on Benefit-Cost Analysis Reports that sits underneath a webpage Evidence in Policy Making. The latter states: "Minnesota is a leader in evidence-based policy making." The former has links to 14 CBA reports on under 7 topics:
* Substance Use Disorder.
* Adult Criminal Justice.
* Adult Mental Health.
* Child Welfare.
* Children's Mental Health.
* Higher Education.
* Juvenile Justice.
The MN PUC's website has an Economic Analysis webpage without any guides to CBA, EIA are similar. It simply asserts that: "The Econ Unit looks at utility programs, policies, and tariffs to figure out how they impact consumers[.]"
The MN Department of Transportation's website does have a webpage on Benefit-Cost Analysis for Transportation Projects, which states that: "This document is intended to provide guidance to perform benefit-cost analysis for highway projects. The guidance includes:
* Section 2: What is Benefit-Cost Analysis?
* Section 3: How Does Benefit-Cost Analysis fit into the Project Development Process?
* Section 4: Economic Terms and Principles.
* Section 5: Conducting a Benefit-Cost Analysis.
* Section 6: Questions.
* Appendix A: Recommended Economic Values.
* Example Spreadsheet."
My 2017 book of the Ten Principles of Regulation & Reform has a chapter on Comparative Risk Assessment (CRA) as well as a chapter on CBA. Typical CBA steps include:
* 1) defining & deciding: a) the goals of the situation or action (X) of concern (e.g., outputs/outcomes sought from policy or investment project); b) on none, one or more 'counter-factual' alternatives (Y) to the policy or investment project; c) from who's viewpoint/s will benefits and costs be analyzed (i.e., standing); d) on one or more CBA 'success' decision criteria such as net present value (NPV), benefit cost ratio (BCR), internal rate of return (IRR), net benefit investment ratio (NBIR) &/or social return on investment (SROI).
* 2) identifying & quantifying: e) non-money impacts or quantities (Q) of the policy or
* investment project (e.g., outputs/outcomes achieved); f) money values or prices ($P) of the benefits & costs (e.g., social = external + private); g) risk & uncertainty (R&U) directly into impacts or values, or indirectly into the discount rate; h) inflation (I) directly into values, or indirectly into the discount rate.
* 3) calculating & comparing: i) aggregate benefits ($B) less aggregate costs ($C) - i.e., net benefits or costs ($NBC = $B - $C); j) discounted net benefits or costs ($DNBC), at one or more discount rates (DR%); k) decision criteria (DC) such as NPV of project X > $0 &/or NPV of project X > NPV of project Y; l) distributions of $B, $C & $DNBC (e.g., at least, those with CBA standing); m) sensitivities of DR and I, as well as the key Ps, Qs & R&Us (e.g., at least, best-case, worst-case & most-likely-case).
Former Chairman of the Australian Productivity Commission (PC), Professor Gary Banks A.O., gave a speech on February 4, 2009 regarding Evidence-based policy-making: What is it? How do we get it? including the following important points:
* [W]ithin Government itself, many of us today find ourselves laughing knowingly at the antics of The Hollow Men, just as we did with Yes Minister; and perhaps also cringing in recognition at how a carefully crafted policy proposal can be so easily subverted, or a dubious policy can triumph with little real evidence or analysis to commend it.
* It is as important that we have a rigorous, evidence-based approach to public policy in Australia [and Minnesota] today as at any time in our history. ... We should not underestimate the significance of those challenges [like MN nuclear power], which place a premium on enhancing the efficiency and productivity of our economy.
* The term 'evidence-based policy making' has been most recently popularised by the [UK's] Blair Government, which was elected on a platform of 'what matters is what works'. Blair spoke of ending ideologically-based decision making and 'questioning inherited ways of doing things'. Of course, 'inherited ways of doing things' meant to the Blair Government the ways of the previous Thatcher administration!
* [K]ey economic policy reforms that have drawn heavily on evidence-based reviews/evaluations include the exchange rate and financial market liberalisation of the 1980s, the National Competition Policy reforms of the 1990s and the shift to inflation targeting in monetary policy in 1993. ... While the systematic evaluation and review of policy have not been pervasive --and arguably have been less evident in the social and environmental domains than the economic -- Australia's experience illustrates its potential contribution
* Arguably the biggest-ever case of policy-making under uncertainty is the contemporary challenge posed by global warming. With huge residual uncertainties in the science, economics and (international) politics, there can be little confidence that anyone could identify a uniquely 'correct' policy prescription for Australia [or Minnesota] at this point. The only sensible way forward, therefore, is to start gradually, to monitor, to learn by doing as we develop institutions and see the effects of carbon pricing on our economy and community, and as we wait for others to come to the party -- in other words, an adaptive response.
* [P]olicies are not made in a vacuum. Rather, they typically emerge from a maelstrom of political energy, vested interests and lobbying. Commonly, those with special interests will try to align their demands with the public interest. The average person (voter) rationally doesn't do the hard work necessary to find out whether that is correct or not, but often feels intuitively supportive. In that 'realpolitik', evidence and analysis that is robust and publicly available can serve as an important counterweight to the influence of sectional interests, enabling the wider community to be better informed about what is at stake in interest groups' proposals, and enfranchising those who would bear the costs of implementing them[.]
The essential ingredients of evidence-based policy making are:
* Methodology matters.
* Good data is a pre-requisite.
* Real evidence is open to scrutiny.
* Evidence-building takes time.
* Good evidence requires good people.
* Independence can be crucial.
* A receptive policy-making environment is fundamental.
* Making better use of existing processes.
* Effective inter-governmental and stakeholder arrangements.
* Building greater institutional capacity.
* Better use of external contracting.
* Resourcing evaluations properly.
Public safety and emergency planning
22. How could a new nuclear generating facility affect public safety officials and emergency responders in the host community and surrounding areas? You may consider emergency planning and response responsibilities, staffing and training needs, equipment and infrastructure needs, coordination among local, state, Tribal, federal, and facility personnel, potential costs, and how those costs should be allocated.
No further comment.
Minnesota energy and climate goals
23. How would new nuclear generation affect Minnesota's statutory greenhouse gas reduction and carbon-free electricity goals? Please consider potential contributions, limitations, timelines, lifecycle emissions, and interactions with other electricity resources.
As MPR reported on March 2, 2023:
* Utilities are expected to add a lot of solar and wind to help reach [the] goal [of getting 100% of their electricity from carbon-free sources by 2040]. But nuclear advocates say they also will need a reliable, consistent source of energy when the sun isn't shining or the wind isn't blowing. Unlike coal or natural gas, nuclear plants don't emit greenhouse gases that contribute to climate change, such as carbon dioxide.
* Fresh Energy, a nonprofit advocacy group, wrote that advanced nuclear technology "does have significant potential and is worth considering as a serious option," as the state works to eliminate carbon emissions from the power sector.
* Eric Meyer, founder and director of a nuclear advocacy nonprofit called Generation Atomic, said "when you hold up a (uranium) pellet and tell people that this is the equivalent to a ton of coal in terms of its energy value -- for a lot of people, it's like, 'Wow, this is the closest thing we have to magic.'"
* Xcel Energy, which owns the two nuclear plants in Minnesota, said it plans to continue operating them to help it achieve carbon-free electricity. It already has plans to reach 80% carbon-free electricity by 2030, but says it will need to explore new technologies that can generate electricity 24/7, and advanced nuclear power is among those.
Ted Nordhaus of the Breakthrough Institute, who helped launch the pro-nuclear environmental movement, wrote on April 16, 2025 that:
* If climate change were a real, existential threat to human societies--an asteroid, not diabetes--nationalizing the power sector and building large proven reactor designs as fast as we can would be both the fastest way to deeply cut emissions and a national imperative in just about every country in the world. Under those circumstances, there wouldn't be much point to deploying a lot of wind and solar as well. You'd just overbuild nuclear a bit to account for peak demand and run most of the plants most of the time. The current regulatory regime wouldn't need that much change either.
* But that is not the sort of problem climate change is. Despite three decades of escalating rhetoric from advocates, it has not, and will not, motivate the same sort of response as the oil shocks of the 1970s, which motivated much of the global nuclear build out around the world. A decade ago, as the pro-nuclear movement was finding its legs, the underpants gnomes were a lot more useful. But today, we've won that debate. Both the public and policymakers, across the political spectrum, are with us.
* What you learn once you've been at that for a while is that getting from here to there is hard, not easy. Nobody knows how to build a large conventional reactor in a liberalized electricity market and no one knows how to license and build a small, non-light water reactor in any market. Until we crack one or both of those codes, a future powered by abundant nuclear energy will remain a dream, not a reality.
Development timelines
24. What timelines should Minnesota anticipate for new nuclear projects, from initial planning and permitting through construction and operation? You may identify timelines for different nuclear technologies, historical averages for comparable projects, common causes of delay, opportunities to shorten timelines, and remaining uncertainties.
The recent midterms resulted in a win for now Governor-elect Amy Klobuchar. Her campaign platform priorities of most relevance to "new nuclear projects" are reproduced below:
* Lower Costs for Minnesotans. As Governor, Amy Klobuchar will work to lower costs that have been going through the roof across the country -- essentials like...utility bills. ... And she'll hold the line on utility bills by modernizing Minnesota's power grid and adding more affordable, renewable energy.
* Make Government Accountable and Root out Fraud. Amy Klobuchar intends to transform our state government to be innovative, effective, and accountable. ... It means modern technology that delivers results fast. It means making it easy to start a business and bring good-paying jobs to Minnesota. It means turning the page on a bureaucracy that leaves people dreading having to jump through hoops to get a permit or start a business.
* Expand Minnesota's Rural and Agricultural Economy. Amy Klobuchar knows one-size-fits-all solutions don't work for rural communities. She and her running mate, former Fergus Falls Mayor Ben Schierer, will expand Minnesota's rural economy[.] ... They'll modernize rural broadband and infrastructure[.] ... Together, they will make sure Minnesotans can live, work, and raise a family anywhere in Minnesota -- because kids who grow up in rural Minnesota should be able to stay in rural Minnesota.
Allowing for "new nuclear projects" is very consistent with these three priorities Governor-elect Amy Klobuchar, especially if "adding more affordable, renewable energy" can include clean energy, as in carbon clean, as in nuclear energy.
Minnesota laws and regulations
25. Which current Minnesota statutes or administrative rules would need to be modified to enable the construction and operation of new nuclear reactors? Please identify specific provisions when possible and explain why a change may or may not be appropriate.
My work as an energy policy fellow at American Experiment, since I started on June 1, 2026, has mainly focused on the 2026 Minnesota Statutes regarding Utilities in Table of Chapters, 216 - 217.
In general, renewable energy should be redefined throughout as clean energy that includes nuclear energy by name. In particular:
* Modify 216B.1691 Subd. 1. and 216B.243 Subd. 3a. to include nuclear power.
* Repeal 216B.243 Subd. 3b. to end the moratorium on new nuclear power.
Three "specific provisions" that appear to be in most need of "change," in order to "enable the construction and operation of new nuclear reactors," are as follows:
* 216B.1691 Subdivision 1. Definitions. ... (b) "Carbon-free" means a technology that generates electricity without emitting carbon dioxide. (c) Unless otherwise specified in law, "eligible energy technology" means an energy technology that generates electricity from the following renewable energy sources: (1) solar; (2) wind; (3) hydroelectric... (4) hydrogen... (5) biomass...
* 216B.243 Subd. 3a. Use of renewable resource. The commission may not issue a certificate of need under this section for a large energy facility that generates electric power by means of a nonrenewable energy source, unless the applicant for the certificate has demonstrated to the commission's satisfaction that it has explored the possibility of generating power by means of renewable energy sources and has demonstrated that the alternative selected is less expensive, including environmental costs, than power generated by a renewable energy source. For purposes of this subdivision, "renewable energy source" includes hydro, wind, solar, and geothermal energy and the use of trees or other vegetation as fuel.
* 216B.243 Subd. 3b. Nuclear power plant; new construction prohibited; relicensing. (a) The commission may not issue a certificate of need for the construction of a new nuclear-powered electric generating plant.
Note that the there appear to be three existing "specific provisions" that might help to better "enable the construction and operation of new nuclear reactors," as follows:
* 216A.05 Subd. 6 Operation with regard to federal law. The commission is authorized: (1) to cooperate with all federal agencies for the purpose of harmonizing state and federal regulations within the state... (2) to conduct joint hearings with any federal agency or commission...
* 216A.07 Subd. 6 Mission; efficiency; legislative report, recommendations. It is part of the department's mission that within the department's resources the commissioner shall endeavor to: ... (7) recommend to the legislature appropriate changes in law necessary to carry out the mission and improve the performance of the department.
* 216H.02 Subdivision 1. Greenhouse gas emissions-reduction goal. ... (b) To the maximum extent practicable, actions taken to achieve these goals must avoid causing disproportionate adverse impacts to residents of communities that are or have been incommensurately exposed to pollution affecting human health and environmental quality.
Regarding 216H.02, see Shattered Green Dreams The Environmental Costs of Wind and Solar.
Replacement of retiring generation
26. How feasible would it be to replace retiring electricity generation facilities in Minnesota with advanced nuclear reactors? Please consider potential locations or types of retiring facilities; existing transmission and interconnection infrastructure; site characteristics and infrastructure that could be reused; workforce requirements; differences in generation capacity and operating characteristics; community interest; environmental remediation; cost; and project timing.
No further comment.
Workforce and training
27. What workforce would be needed to construct and operate new nuclear reactors in Minnesota? Please address the types of occupations, skills, and credentials, as well as the approximate workforce needs, associated with different technologies and project phases.
No further comment.
28. To what extent is the necessary workforce currently available?
No further comment.
29. What education, apprenticeship, training, recruitment, or workforce development capacity would be needed to support new nuclear construction and operation? Please identify specific training and capacity needs as well as potential roles for labor organizations, educational institutions, employers, government agencies, or other partners.
No further comment.
Additional Information
30. Are there additional studies, datasets, models, projects, experts, or other sources relevant to the questions above that GPI should consider? Please provide links or citations and briefly explain their relevance.
I recommend reaching out to Ryan Sistad, the Executive Director of Better in Our Backyard (BIOBY), who is based not far from the Twin Cities: ryan@betterinourbackyard.com. BIOBY's members and experts might be able to suggest "additional studies, datasets, models, projects, experts, or other sources relevant to the questions above that GPI should consider."
* As Better in Our Back Yard's executive director, Ryan connects with public officials, business leaders and communities to share a positive, pro-industry message. Better in Our Back Yard advocates for federal permitting reform, critical minerals and domestic energy production to drive a more prosperous future for all.
31. Would you like to upload documents or other materials supporting your response?Please use the file upload option at the bottom of the form linked in the instructions above.
I recommend GPI download the PDF document in the following link: The Commonwealth of Australia's Handbook of Cost Benefit Analysis from January 2006.
I also recommend GPI download my two submissions to the Minnesota Public Utility Commission regarding their current energy affordability investigation:
* PUC energy affordability investigation: public comments due October 16
* PUC energy affordability investigation: public comments due November 6
32. Is there anything else GPI should consider when evaluating the potential impacts of new nuclear generation on the public interest in Minnesota?
Context matters. And when it comes to why the moratorium on new nuclear power should be lifted, context is crucial. Therefore:
* Wind and solar renewables are still, as of 2024, vastly more costly than nuclear, coal or natural gas reliables (see Chart 1 below).
* Wind has been the dominant renewable in MN in the 21st century, especially since 2004, with solar a distant second even in the 2020s (see Chart 2 below).
* MN renewables went from an afterthought, prior to the 21st century, to the top generation source nowadays, along with natural gas not far behind (see Chart 3 below).
* The growth of MN renewables in the 21st century has far outpaced that of the rest of the midwest (MW) region and the country (US) as a whole (see Chart 4 below).
* Twin Cities (MSP) electricity CPI inflation has thus, also far outpaced that of the MW and US in the 21st century (see Chart 5 below).
* MSP electricity CPI inflation has outpaced MSP general CPI inflation throughout the 21st century, as well as overtaking it in the 2010s and 2020s (see Chart 6 below).
* MN electricity rates have inflated by well over 100% in the 21st century for residential, commercial, industrial and total combined customer classes (see Chart 7 below).
* MN's state rankings on these four electricity rates have sunk throughout the 21st century, from almost top 10 for commercial in 2002, to almost bottom 10 for industrial 2022 (see Chart 8 below).
* These heavily inflating MN electricity rates have translated into skyrocketing electricity bills, on average for the three main customer classes combined (see Chart 9 below).
* MN electricity bills inflation is being driven up by increased rates and not by increased uses, noting { Bills = Revenues / Customers } and { Revenues = Rates x Uses } (see Chart 10 below).
* MN electricity uses peaked in 2008 and has sunk since, and given the Jevons paradox and Khazzoom-Brookes postulate, this strongly suggests not electricity cost efficiency but electricity price inflation (see Chart 11 below).
* This is very much reinforced by comparing MN electricity price inflation to MN natural gas price deflation between 2002 and 2025 (see Chart 12 below).
* This is also reinforced by comparing MN electricity revenues to MN natural gas revenues, the former of which are being pushed up by rates not uses, which in turn are being pushed up by renewables capex not equity returns (see Charts 13 and 14 below).
* * *
Darren Nelson is a Policy Fellow at Center of the American Experiment. darren.nelson@americanexperiment.org
* * *
Original text here: https://www.americanexperiment.org/mn-nuclear-energy-study-rfi-response-2/
[Category: ThinkTank]
* * *
MN nuclear energy study: RFI response #2
Written by Darren Nelson
November 14, 2026
This is a copy of my second response, on behalf of American Experiment, to the Request for Information (RFI) from the public by the Great Plains Institute (GPI) regarding the Minnesota Nuclear Energy Study (MNES). The study began on July 1, 2026 and ends by January 30, 2027.
GPI have been contracted to undertake this ... Show Full Article MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 15 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary: * * * MN nuclear energy study: RFI response #2 Written by Darren Nelson November 14, 2026 This is a copy of my second response, on behalf of American Experiment, to the Request for Information (RFI) from the public by the Great Plains Institute (GPI) regarding the Minnesota Nuclear Energy Study (MNES). The study began on July 1, 2026 and ends by January 30, 2027. GPI have been contracted to undertake thisstudy by the Minnesota Department of Commerce at the direction of the Minnesota Legislature under HF 2438. Regarding the RFI, the GPI MNES website states the following:
* The formal Request for Information [RFI] period, open from August 14, 2026, through September 14, 2026, has ended. Submissions of relevant information may still be submitted until November 16, 2026 using the online form linked below. After November 16, no new information will be able to be submitted through the online form.
This second response or submission is in addition to my first one from September 14, 2026. Both are structured according to GPI's 32 guiding questions and 13 topic headings as follows:
* Federal licensing => Q1
* Technology and costs => Q2 to Q8
* Small modular reactors and other advanced technologies => Q9
* Siting and infrastructure => Q10 to Q16
* Nuclear waste => Q17 to Q20
* Host community economic impacts => Q21
* Public safety and emergency planning => Q22
* Minnesota energy and climate goals => Q23
* Development timelines => Q24
* Minnesota laws and regulations => Q25
* Replacement of retiring generation => Q26
* Workforce and training => Q27 to Q29
* Additional Information => Q30 to Q32
Federal licensing
1. How might recent or anticipated changes in federal regulations governing the licensing of nuclear-powered facilities affect the review and approval of such facilities? Please identify any specific regulatory changes, expected effects on licensing timelines, and any supporting sources.
No further comment.
Technology and costs
2. What technological advances have been made with respect to conventional nuclear-powered facilities that affect safety and cost? Please identify specific technology advances and how they impact safety and/or cost.
No further comment.
3. What information should the study consider when evaluating the full lifecycle costs of nuclear generation compared with alternative baseload resource options? Please identify any relevant information regarding capital costs, financing costs, construction risks, cost and schedule overruns, operating and maintenance costs, decommissioning costs, waste management costs, long-term liability exposure, historical experience from comparable projects in the United States or internationally, and other relevant costs or risks.
Chart 1 below shows a comprehensive Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE), where nuclear generation at $37.18 per MWh is less expensive by:
* 1.3x times combined cycle at $50.03;
* 2.4x times than coal at $89.79;
* 3.1x times than natural gas at $115.83;
* 7.9x times than wind at $296.97; and
* 13.3x times than solar at $496.16.
[View chart in the link at bottom]
4. What information should the study consider when evaluating the full life costs of alternative baseload resource options, and why? Please identify relevant technologies and information regarding capital costs, financing costs, construction risks, cost and schedule overruns, operating and maintenance costs, decommissioning costs, waste management costs, long-term liability exposure, historical experience from comparable projects in the United States or internationally, and other relevant costs or risks.
It is important to note that: nuclear power is the best when it comes to total life cycle CO2; plus wind and solar are not without environmental costs, as documented by American Experiment in Shattered Green Dreams. Highlights from this landmark report include:
* A wide variety and large quantity of minerals are used in solar panels, wind turbines, battery storage, transmission lines, and more. The US currently sources most of its minerals from foreign countries that do not adhere to modern environmental or worker health and safety standards.
* The low electricity density of wind and solar generation means that they require at least 10 times as much land per unit of power produced as coal or natural gas-fired power plants. If the US were powered entirely by wind turbines, the land area necessary would exceed two Californias.
* Some components in wind turbines and solar panels are hazardous. Current recycling pathways are uneconomic and underutilized, which means that decommissioned wind turbines and solar panels often end up in landfills.
* The operating lifespan of wind turbines and solar panels is between 20 and 25 years at maximum, while natural gas plants may operate for 40 years, and nuclear plants operate between 40 and 80 years. Decommissioning and repowering wind and solar energy is required more often than other forms of electricity generation, compounding costs.
5. What evidence from nuclear projects developed in the United States or internationally should inform the study's analysis of costs, construction risks, and project performance? Please provide project names, data, reports, or other sources when possible.
No further comment.
6. What information should the study consider when evaluating how the development of new nuclear generation could affect Minnesota ratepayers and electricity rates? You may address effects on electricity rates, construction cost and schedule overruns unrelated to unique events, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, how financial risks could be allocated between ratepayers, utilities, developers, investors, or other parties, and approaches that could protect ratepayers from financial risk.
The Averch-Johnson (A-J) Effect is a well-known concept in economic regulation of a strong tendency, by public utilities and their regulators, towards "gold plating" of the capital base.
Economics Professor Kenneth Train of UC Berkeley wrote a book chapter on The Averch-Johnson Model of Rate-of-Return Regulation in 1991, that had the following observation:
* Averch and Johnson (1962) initiated one of the earliest and most influential investigations into the effects of regulation on the behavior of a regulated firm. They argue that the most prevalent form of regulation currently applied to public utilities, rate-of-return regulation, induces the firm to engage in inefficiencies. These inefficiencies are the natural result of the regulation. Furthermore, the aspects of monopoly control that regulation is intended to address, such as high prices, are not necessarily mitigated, and could be made worse, by the regulation.
The Federal Reserve published a paper by two of their economists in 1987 entitled A Test of Two Views of the Regulatory Mechanism: Averch-Johnson and Joskow. Highlights include:
* Electric utility regulators attempt to maintain a competitive price for electricity by adjusting the rate of return on a utility's capital. However, there are potentially serious problems with this type of regulation related to consumer reactions to price increases and to the types of incentives given to utilities. First, price increases may lower the consumption of electricity, which may reduce earned rates of return below "fair" rates and trigger a price increase, which in turn may lower consumption and trigger another price increase, and so on. Second, utilities may be able to effect price increases by using "too much" capital, that is, by overcapitalizing, which inflates their rate base. Finally, the ability to pass along operating cost increases that originated from productivity declines suggests that utilities may not have the incentive to raise productivity.
Professors Paul Joskow and Richard Schmalensee's addressed the A-J Effect in their 2024 book chapter on Cost of Service Regulation of Electricity Distribution Services in the US:
* In our view, the most important intellectual contribution of the Averch-Johnson paper is not the capital bias result, but rather that it got economists thinking about the implications of various regulatory mechanisms for the regulated firm's costs. In the end, we believe that traditional COSR [cost of service or rate of return regulation] of legal monopolies does lead to inefficiencies, mainly for all of the reasons articulated in the incentive regulation literature.
7. What public subsidies, tax expenditures, financial incentives, or financing mechanisms could apply to new nuclear investments in Minnesota?
The PUC system of electricity revenues and rates setting has been biased in favor of inflating the capital base throughout the 20th century, but has been biased in favor of doing so through wind and solar renewables throughout the 21st century.
Both the capital bias and the renewables bias will probably require legislative reform, but in the meantime the PUC can learn from, and look to apply, incentive regulation. Professors Joskow and Schmalensee of MIT discuss incentive regulation at length:
* There is by now a very extensive and mature theoretical literature on incentive regulation of legal monopolies. Incentive regulation mechanisms have been applied for many years to the regulation of electric utilities in countries other than the US, including Great Britain, New Zealand, Australia, and Canada. Incentive regulation mechanisms of some type have now been introduced into the electricity distribution regulatory process in a majority of US states. These initiatives are never called "incentive regulation" by regulators and policy makers in the US. The policy phrases used routinely now are "performance-based regulation" (PBR) or "alternative regulatory mechanisms" (ARM).
* RPI-X regulation (sometimes called price-cap regulation) [was originally applied] to the newly privatized British Telecom beginning in 1983 and thereafter to all regulated [public utilities] in the UK. Under this system the rate of growth of a weighted average of the regulated firm's prices is constrained not to exceed the rate of growth of the RPI (retail price index) minus X [the opex and capex efficiency factor], set after negotiation by the regulator. It was initially hoped that once X had been set, this system could simply run until competition made regulation redundant, but that did not happen.
The Australian public utilities regulator for the state of New South Wales, IPART, wrote about Incentives for cost saving in CPI-X regimes in July 2011. Highlights from that paper include:
* CPI-X regulation involves setting a price-path (price-cap regulation) for a utility, allowing for changes in inflation (the CPI factor) and expected efficiency improvements (the 'X' factor).
* The 'X' factor may incorporate other aspects in addition to the expected improvement in efficiency, such as rewards for improvements in output quality, service levels or demand management actions.
* Regulators generally aim to set prices/revenues along a path that will generate sufficient revenue to recover the efficient levels of opex and capex, with a reasonable after-tax return on capital.
* The inherent incentives for cost or efficiency savings in the standard CPI-X regime...arise principally because the regime disconnects prices from cost movements after the price path has been set in relation to forecast costs for the period in question.
* This delinking of costs from prices creates an incentive for the regulated firm to cut costs early in a determination period because it retains those cost savings until they are passed through to consumers in lower prices.
* The delinking also creates a counter-incentive to delay until the start of the next determination period any cost savings that would have been done later in the current determination period.
* To preserve the strength of the incentive throughout a determination or control period, both Ofwat and the AER use a carryover mechanism. This mechanism allows utilities to retain, for a period of time at least equal to the length of the control period, the cost-savings that result from improvements in efficiency.
* Ofgem decided to no longer distinguish between opex and capex for the purpose of calculating required revenue. Instead, it treats all expenditure as 'totex' and allocates 85% of it to be recouped from depreciation and a return on capital.
8. How might these measures affect project feasibility, ratepayers, taxpayers, developers, or other parties?
Senator Amy Klobuchar has a web page devoted to Competition Policy that states: "Strong competition policy is necessary to build a vibrant economy that works for consumers, for workers, for entrepreneurs, for local communities, and for companies, large and small." I wrote about Australia's public utilities related Competition Policy in October 2026:
* Market competition is a means to an end. That end is greater freedom to choose, for consumers and suppliers. The main obstacle to that is government. That includes so called 'natural' monopolies and 'public' utilities.
* Australia tested how 'natural' and 'public' these really were, between 1995 and 2005, through National Competition Policy (NCP).
* NCP reforms involved the following: removing anti-competitive regulation and legislation; separating the non-monopoly from the monopoly parts of large state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and government-sponsored enterprises; ensuring competitive neutrality for non-monopoly SOEs; formalizing oversight of pricing for monopoly SOEs, and using incentive regulation; creating a third-party access regime for monopoly infrastructure, whether SOE or not; extending antitrust laws to all SOEs; and having states and territories apply these reforms to local government.
* NCP was directly applied to the following infrastructure industries: electricity (federal and state); natural gas (state); roads (federal, state, and local); and water and sewage (federal, state, and local). It was also designed to indirectly target airports (federal and local), ports (state), postal (federal), rail (federal and state), and telecommunications (federal).
* Policymakers implemented NCP through three agreements between the federal, state, and territorial governments. Annual performance-based payments were provided to the states for nine years, some of which the state of Queensland passed on to local governments for five years to incentivize NCP reform at that level.
* A small 'guide-and-watch dog' called the National Competition Council (NCC) was established to assess progress and make payments on an annual basis.
* Cost-benefit analyses were embedded in every aspect of NCP, including in three major assessments of the economic impacts in 1995, 1999, and 2005. The 2005 assessment found there was a massive net-benefit (benefits over costs) from NCP, i.e. competition performance above competition payments.
* The sowing of $5.5 Billion in taxpayer payments during the NCP decade conservatively reaped more than $1 Trillion in additional benefits for Australians, gained "from productivity and price reductions observed over the 1990s in the electricity, gas, urban water, telecommunications, urban transport, ports and rail freight sectors." This economic return was of Biblical proportions, well over a hundred-fold!
Small modular reactors and other advanced technologies
9. What should the study consider when evaluating the prospects for small modular reactors and factory-built portable modules with a capacity of up to 300 megawatts?Please address any of the following: technologies that are currently available or under development; current federal licensing status; estimated capital, operating, and lifecycle costs; commercial readiness, potential applications in Minnesota; key uncertainties or barriers; relevant projects, studies, or data.
No further comment.
Siting and infrastructure
10. How could the need for water resources for cooling affect where new nuclear facilities could be located in Minnesota? Please identify the cooling needs of different nuclear technologies; the extent to which water requirements could restrict possible locations; potentially suitable locations or types of locations in Minnesota; and the environmental, ecological, climate, or competing-use considerations associated with water use.
No further comment.
11. What is the potential for colocating new nuclear facilities with businesses or facilities that use very large amounts of electricity?
No further comment.
12. What are the environmental and public health impacts of new nuclear facilities? Please identify impacts during construction, operation, decommissioning, and waste management, including potential effects on nearby residents.
According to the US Department of Energy, under President Joe Biden, on March 31, 2021 there are 3 Reasons Why Nuclear is Clean and Sustainable:
* Nuclear energy protects air quality.
* Nuclear energy's land footprint is small.
* Nuclear energy produces minimal waste.
* Nuclear is a zero-emission clean energy source. It also keeps the air clean by removing thousands of tons of harmful air pollutants each year that contribute to acid rain, smog, lung cancer and cardiovascular disease. The US avoided more than 471 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions in 2020. That's the equivalent of removing 100 million cars from the road and more than all other clean energy sources combined.
* A typical 1,000-megawatt nuclear facility in the US needs a little more than 1 square mile to operate. Wind farms require 360 times more land area to produce the same amount of electricity and solar photovoltaic plants require 75 times more space. To put that in perspective, you would need more than 3 million solar panels to produce the same amount of power as a typical commercial reactor or more than 430 wind turbines (capacity factor not included).
* All of the used nuclear fuel produced by the US nuclear energy industry over the last 60 years could fit on a football field at a depth of less than 10 yards! That waste can also be reprocessed and recycled, although the US does not currently do this. However, some advanced reactor designs being developed could operate on used fuel.
13. What information should the study consider that would inform the prospects for acceptance of new nuclear facilities by host communities?
See my comments below for Q15.
14. What factors could affect whether a host community would support or oppose a new nuclear facility?
See my comments below for Q15.
15. What best practices should be used to engage potential host communities and nearby residents regarding new nuclear facilities? Please consider when engagement should begin, who should be included, what information should be available, and how community input should inform decisions.
I believe NIMBYnomics offers some valuable insights for Q13, Q14 and Q15 as follows:
* NIMBY stands for "Not In My back Yard." This is a truly bipartisan phenomenon that helps block all sorts of economic development at the local level, and sometimes state and federal. Blocking nuclear power and family housing are examples of typical Left NIMBYism. Blocking wind and solar power and public housing are examples of typical Right NIMBYism. Blocking data centers is the prime example of combined Left, Right and Center NIMBYism. The key to better understanding and addressing NIMBYism is Public Choice economics.
* One important insight from Public Choice is that there is not just a civilian marketplace but also a political marketplace that both obey the laws of self-interested demand and supply. A second important insight is that democracy is rarely a romantic endeavour but a dirty business where private interests, of the majority or minority, often defeat the public interest. A third important insight is that special interests have greater incentives, of a monetary or psych nature, to be very active in politics. Economists call them "Bootleggers and Baptists."
* The issue of concentrated costs versus diffuse benefits is the economic root of the NIMBY problem. Hindering negotiated compensation solutions to NIMBY problems are transaction costs, or the "costs of engaging in economic calculation" based on market prices and property rights. It is an old saying that "everyone has a price." Institutions can better align rights, costs and benefits to allow developers and NIMBYs to negotiate, and legally pay, a compensation price.
* In politics and policy, special interests often gazump the public interest. NIMBYism is one increasingly common example of this, especially in terms of data centers and nuclear power. NIMBYs are motivated by strong incentives of concentrated costs, monetary and non-monetary. Development advocates are motivated by weaker incentives of dispersed benefits. NIMBY "Bootleggers" can often be bought off at the right compensation price and in the right institutional circumstances. NIMBY "Baptists" sometimes and increasingly cannot.
* Today, Minnesota is sliding into something worse [than NIMBY, "Not In My Backyard"]: BANANA, or "Build Absolutely Nothing Anywhere Near Anything." It's no longer about location. It's about stopping the project, period, no matter where it is, how it's run or how much it benefits Minnesota. - Pat Garofalo, "Minnesota's slide from NIMBY to BANANA" July 20, 2026
16. How could electric transmission capacity, grid interconnection requirements, or related infrastructure affect potential locations and development timelines for new nuclear facilities?
Utility Dive reported on November 10, 2026 that:
* The Senate voted Monday to advance the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a major piece of permitting reform legislation, but some experts and lawmakers have voiced skepticism about its future in the lame duck session following midterm elections in which Democrats handily won control of both chambers of Congress.
* In a research note sent Monday following the vote, Jefferies analysts said the manager's amendment "largely preserves" the bill's original framework "but is incrementally better for transmission, offshore-wind projects, nuclear, and non-RTO utilities, and worse for large BTM gas configurations, incumbent RTO utilities and projects relying on strong permit certainty."
* Former FERC Chairman Mark Christie said in a Monday LinkedIn post that the manager's amendment had not "at all" addressed two of his three major concerns with the legislation. "The 'public interest' standard in the bill remains a blank check for FERC to override the states and order trillions of dollars in new transmission built to fit the policies of a President or more likely, special interest lobbying of RTOs." He added that the legislation doesn't give states authority over cost allocation for large transmission projects "that will cost their consumers tons of money."
* Paul Cicio, CEO of the trade association Industrial Energy Consumers of America and chair of the Electricity Transmission Competition Coalition, criticized the bill in a Monday LinkedIn post, saying it "fails to unleash transmission competition and deliver cost savings to ratepayers." He also said, "without competition, a monopoly utility has zero incentive to reduce costs. Section 2105 codifies existing exceptions to competition that are used by the monopoly utilities to evade competition."
Nuclear waste
17. What information should the study consider regarding the amount and toxicity of radioactive waste produced by conventional nuclear technologies and small modular reactors? Please identify differences among technologies and provide supporting evidence or sources when available.
No further comment.
18. What should the study consider when evaluating the costs, risks, and long-term requirements of storing nuclear waste on-site?
No further comment.
19. What are the prospects for developing a permanent, federally or privately owned repository to which nuclear waste from Minnesota could be transported? Please address relevant technical, regulatory, legal, financial, political, transportation, or timing considerations.
No further comment.
20. What should the study consider when evaluating the feasibility and cost of reprocessing nuclear waste? Please identify potential benefits, risks, limitations, or relevant examples.
No further comment.
Host community economic impacts
21. What economic impacts could different nuclear technologies have on a host community? Please consider employment during construction, long-term employment during operations, local purchases by a nuclear facility and its employees, effects on local businesses and economic activity, tax revenue for local governments and schools, state tax revenue, potential costs to the host community, differences among conventional reactors, small modular reactors, and other advanced technologies.
Both Minnesota Management and Budget (MMB) and the Public Utilities Commission (PUC) should be encouraged to create, sooner rather than later, official guidelines on cost benefit analysis (CBA) and economic impact analysis (EIA).
The MMB website has a webpage on Benefit-Cost Analysis Reports that sits underneath a webpage Evidence in Policy Making. The latter states: "Minnesota is a leader in evidence-based policy making." The former has links to 14 CBA reports on under 7 topics:
* Substance Use Disorder.
* Adult Criminal Justice.
* Adult Mental Health.
* Child Welfare.
* Children's Mental Health.
* Higher Education.
* Juvenile Justice.
The MN PUC's website has an Economic Analysis webpage without any guides to CBA, EIA are similar. It simply asserts that: "The Econ Unit looks at utility programs, policies, and tariffs to figure out how they impact consumers[.]"
The MN Department of Transportation's website does have a webpage on Benefit-Cost Analysis for Transportation Projects, which states that: "This document is intended to provide guidance to perform benefit-cost analysis for highway projects. The guidance includes:
* Section 2: What is Benefit-Cost Analysis?
* Section 3: How Does Benefit-Cost Analysis fit into the Project Development Process?
* Section 4: Economic Terms and Principles.
* Section 5: Conducting a Benefit-Cost Analysis.
* Section 6: Questions.
* Appendix A: Recommended Economic Values.
* Example Spreadsheet."
My 2017 book of the Ten Principles of Regulation & Reform has a chapter on Comparative Risk Assessment (CRA) as well as a chapter on CBA. Typical CBA steps include:
* 1) defining & deciding: a) the goals of the situation or action (X) of concern (e.g., outputs/outcomes sought from policy or investment project); b) on none, one or more 'counter-factual' alternatives (Y) to the policy or investment project; c) from who's viewpoint/s will benefits and costs be analyzed (i.e., standing); d) on one or more CBA 'success' decision criteria such as net present value (NPV), benefit cost ratio (BCR), internal rate of return (IRR), net benefit investment ratio (NBIR) &/or social return on investment (SROI).
* 2) identifying & quantifying: e) non-money impacts or quantities (Q) of the policy or
* investment project (e.g., outputs/outcomes achieved); f) money values or prices ($P) of the benefits & costs (e.g., social = external + private); g) risk & uncertainty (R&U) directly into impacts or values, or indirectly into the discount rate; h) inflation (I) directly into values, or indirectly into the discount rate.
* 3) calculating & comparing: i) aggregate benefits ($B) less aggregate costs ($C) - i.e., net benefits or costs ($NBC = $B - $C); j) discounted net benefits or costs ($DNBC), at one or more discount rates (DR%); k) decision criteria (DC) such as NPV of project X > $0 &/or NPV of project X > NPV of project Y; l) distributions of $B, $C & $DNBC (e.g., at least, those with CBA standing); m) sensitivities of DR and I, as well as the key Ps, Qs & R&Us (e.g., at least, best-case, worst-case & most-likely-case).
Former Chairman of the Australian Productivity Commission (PC), Professor Gary Banks A.O., gave a speech on February 4, 2009 regarding Evidence-based policy-making: What is it? How do we get it? including the following important points:
* [W]ithin Government itself, many of us today find ourselves laughing knowingly at the antics of The Hollow Men, just as we did with Yes Minister; and perhaps also cringing in recognition at how a carefully crafted policy proposal can be so easily subverted, or a dubious policy can triumph with little real evidence or analysis to commend it.
* It is as important that we have a rigorous, evidence-based approach to public policy in Australia [and Minnesota] today as at any time in our history. ... We should not underestimate the significance of those challenges [like MN nuclear power], which place a premium on enhancing the efficiency and productivity of our economy.
* The term 'evidence-based policy making' has been most recently popularised by the [UK's] Blair Government, which was elected on a platform of 'what matters is what works'. Blair spoke of ending ideologically-based decision making and 'questioning inherited ways of doing things'. Of course, 'inherited ways of doing things' meant to the Blair Government the ways of the previous Thatcher administration!
* [K]ey economic policy reforms that have drawn heavily on evidence-based reviews/evaluations include the exchange rate and financial market liberalisation of the 1980s, the National Competition Policy reforms of the 1990s and the shift to inflation targeting in monetary policy in 1993. ... While the systematic evaluation and review of policy have not been pervasive --and arguably have been less evident in the social and environmental domains than the economic -- Australia's experience illustrates its potential contribution
* Arguably the biggest-ever case of policy-making under uncertainty is the contemporary challenge posed by global warming. With huge residual uncertainties in the science, economics and (international) politics, there can be little confidence that anyone could identify a uniquely 'correct' policy prescription for Australia [or Minnesota] at this point. The only sensible way forward, therefore, is to start gradually, to monitor, to learn by doing as we develop institutions and see the effects of carbon pricing on our economy and community, and as we wait for others to come to the party -- in other words, an adaptive response.
* [P]olicies are not made in a vacuum. Rather, they typically emerge from a maelstrom of political energy, vested interests and lobbying. Commonly, those with special interests will try to align their demands with the public interest. The average person (voter) rationally doesn't do the hard work necessary to find out whether that is correct or not, but often feels intuitively supportive. In that 'realpolitik', evidence and analysis that is robust and publicly available can serve as an important counterweight to the influence of sectional interests, enabling the wider community to be better informed about what is at stake in interest groups' proposals, and enfranchising those who would bear the costs of implementing them[.]
The essential ingredients of evidence-based policy making are:
* Methodology matters.
* Good data is a pre-requisite.
* Real evidence is open to scrutiny.
* Evidence-building takes time.
* Good evidence requires good people.
* Independence can be crucial.
* A receptive policy-making environment is fundamental.
* Making better use of existing processes.
* Effective inter-governmental and stakeholder arrangements.
* Building greater institutional capacity.
* Better use of external contracting.
* Resourcing evaluations properly.
Public safety and emergency planning
22. How could a new nuclear generating facility affect public safety officials and emergency responders in the host community and surrounding areas? You may consider emergency planning and response responsibilities, staffing and training needs, equipment and infrastructure needs, coordination among local, state, Tribal, federal, and facility personnel, potential costs, and how those costs should be allocated.
No further comment.
Minnesota energy and climate goals
23. How would new nuclear generation affect Minnesota's statutory greenhouse gas reduction and carbon-free electricity goals? Please consider potential contributions, limitations, timelines, lifecycle emissions, and interactions with other electricity resources.
As MPR reported on March 2, 2023:
* Utilities are expected to add a lot of solar and wind to help reach [the] goal [of getting 100% of their electricity from carbon-free sources by 2040]. But nuclear advocates say they also will need a reliable, consistent source of energy when the sun isn't shining or the wind isn't blowing. Unlike coal or natural gas, nuclear plants don't emit greenhouse gases that contribute to climate change, such as carbon dioxide.
* Fresh Energy, a nonprofit advocacy group, wrote that advanced nuclear technology "does have significant potential and is worth considering as a serious option," as the state works to eliminate carbon emissions from the power sector.
* Eric Meyer, founder and director of a nuclear advocacy nonprofit called Generation Atomic, said "when you hold up a (uranium) pellet and tell people that this is the equivalent to a ton of coal in terms of its energy value -- for a lot of people, it's like, 'Wow, this is the closest thing we have to magic.'"
* Xcel Energy, which owns the two nuclear plants in Minnesota, said it plans to continue operating them to help it achieve carbon-free electricity. It already has plans to reach 80% carbon-free electricity by 2030, but says it will need to explore new technologies that can generate electricity 24/7, and advanced nuclear power is among those.
Ted Nordhaus of the Breakthrough Institute, who helped launch the pro-nuclear environmental movement, wrote on April 16, 2025 that:
* If climate change were a real, existential threat to human societies--an asteroid, not diabetes--nationalizing the power sector and building large proven reactor designs as fast as we can would be both the fastest way to deeply cut emissions and a national imperative in just about every country in the world. Under those circumstances, there wouldn't be much point to deploying a lot of wind and solar as well. You'd just overbuild nuclear a bit to account for peak demand and run most of the plants most of the time. The current regulatory regime wouldn't need that much change either.
* But that is not the sort of problem climate change is. Despite three decades of escalating rhetoric from advocates, it has not, and will not, motivate the same sort of response as the oil shocks of the 1970s, which motivated much of the global nuclear build out around the world. A decade ago, as the pro-nuclear movement was finding its legs, the underpants gnomes were a lot more useful. But today, we've won that debate. Both the public and policymakers, across the political spectrum, are with us.
* What you learn once you've been at that for a while is that getting from here to there is hard, not easy. Nobody knows how to build a large conventional reactor in a liberalized electricity market and no one knows how to license and build a small, non-light water reactor in any market. Until we crack one or both of those codes, a future powered by abundant nuclear energy will remain a dream, not a reality.
Development timelines
24. What timelines should Minnesota anticipate for new nuclear projects, from initial planning and permitting through construction and operation? You may identify timelines for different nuclear technologies, historical averages for comparable projects, common causes of delay, opportunities to shorten timelines, and remaining uncertainties.
The recent midterms resulted in a win for now Governor-elect Amy Klobuchar. Her campaign platform priorities of most relevance to "new nuclear projects" are reproduced below:
* Lower Costs for Minnesotans. As Governor, Amy Klobuchar will work to lower costs that have been going through the roof across the country -- essentials like...utility bills. ... And she'll hold the line on utility bills by modernizing Minnesota's power grid and adding more affordable, renewable energy.
* Make Government Accountable and Root out Fraud. Amy Klobuchar intends to transform our state government to be innovative, effective, and accountable. ... It means modern technology that delivers results fast. It means making it easy to start a business and bring good-paying jobs to Minnesota. It means turning the page on a bureaucracy that leaves people dreading having to jump through hoops to get a permit or start a business.
* Expand Minnesota's Rural and Agricultural Economy. Amy Klobuchar knows one-size-fits-all solutions don't work for rural communities. She and her running mate, former Fergus Falls Mayor Ben Schierer, will expand Minnesota's rural economy[.] ... They'll modernize rural broadband and infrastructure[.] ... Together, they will make sure Minnesotans can live, work, and raise a family anywhere in Minnesota -- because kids who grow up in rural Minnesota should be able to stay in rural Minnesota.
Allowing for "new nuclear projects" is very consistent with these three priorities Governor-elect Amy Klobuchar, especially if "adding more affordable, renewable energy" can include clean energy, as in carbon clean, as in nuclear energy.
Minnesota laws and regulations
25. Which current Minnesota statutes or administrative rules would need to be modified to enable the construction and operation of new nuclear reactors? Please identify specific provisions when possible and explain why a change may or may not be appropriate.
My work as an energy policy fellow at American Experiment, since I started on June 1, 2026, has mainly focused on the 2026 Minnesota Statutes regarding Utilities in Table of Chapters, 216 - 217.
In general, renewable energy should be redefined throughout as clean energy that includes nuclear energy by name. In particular:
* Modify 216B.1691 Subd. 1. and 216B.243 Subd. 3a. to include nuclear power.
* Repeal 216B.243 Subd. 3b. to end the moratorium on new nuclear power.
Three "specific provisions" that appear to be in most need of "change," in order to "enable the construction and operation of new nuclear reactors," are as follows:
* 216B.1691 Subdivision 1. Definitions. ... (b) "Carbon-free" means a technology that generates electricity without emitting carbon dioxide. (c) Unless otherwise specified in law, "eligible energy technology" means an energy technology that generates electricity from the following renewable energy sources: (1) solar; (2) wind; (3) hydroelectric... (4) hydrogen... (5) biomass...
* 216B.243 Subd. 3a. Use of renewable resource. The commission may not issue a certificate of need under this section for a large energy facility that generates electric power by means of a nonrenewable energy source, unless the applicant for the certificate has demonstrated to the commission's satisfaction that it has explored the possibility of generating power by means of renewable energy sources and has demonstrated that the alternative selected is less expensive, including environmental costs, than power generated by a renewable energy source. For purposes of this subdivision, "renewable energy source" includes hydro, wind, solar, and geothermal energy and the use of trees or other vegetation as fuel.
* 216B.243 Subd. 3b. Nuclear power plant; new construction prohibited; relicensing. (a) The commission may not issue a certificate of need for the construction of a new nuclear-powered electric generating plant.
Note that the there appear to be three existing "specific provisions" that might help to better "enable the construction and operation of new nuclear reactors," as follows:
* 216A.05 Subd. 6 Operation with regard to federal law. The commission is authorized: (1) to cooperate with all federal agencies for the purpose of harmonizing state and federal regulations within the state... (2) to conduct joint hearings with any federal agency or commission...
* 216A.07 Subd. 6 Mission; efficiency; legislative report, recommendations. It is part of the department's mission that within the department's resources the commissioner shall endeavor to: ... (7) recommend to the legislature appropriate changes in law necessary to carry out the mission and improve the performance of the department.
* 216H.02 Subdivision 1. Greenhouse gas emissions-reduction goal. ... (b) To the maximum extent practicable, actions taken to achieve these goals must avoid causing disproportionate adverse impacts to residents of communities that are or have been incommensurately exposed to pollution affecting human health and environmental quality.
Regarding 216H.02, see Shattered Green Dreams The Environmental Costs of Wind and Solar.
Replacement of retiring generation
26. How feasible would it be to replace retiring electricity generation facilities in Minnesota with advanced nuclear reactors? Please consider potential locations or types of retiring facilities; existing transmission and interconnection infrastructure; site characteristics and infrastructure that could be reused; workforce requirements; differences in generation capacity and operating characteristics; community interest; environmental remediation; cost; and project timing.
No further comment.
Workforce and training
27. What workforce would be needed to construct and operate new nuclear reactors in Minnesota? Please address the types of occupations, skills, and credentials, as well as the approximate workforce needs, associated with different technologies and project phases.
No further comment.
28. To what extent is the necessary workforce currently available?
No further comment.
29. What education, apprenticeship, training, recruitment, or workforce development capacity would be needed to support new nuclear construction and operation? Please identify specific training and capacity needs as well as potential roles for labor organizations, educational institutions, employers, government agencies, or other partners.
No further comment.
Additional Information
30. Are there additional studies, datasets, models, projects, experts, or other sources relevant to the questions above that GPI should consider? Please provide links or citations and briefly explain their relevance.
I recommend reaching out to Ryan Sistad, the Executive Director of Better in Our Backyard (BIOBY), who is based not far from the Twin Cities: ryan@betterinourbackyard.com. BIOBY's members and experts might be able to suggest "additional studies, datasets, models, projects, experts, or other sources relevant to the questions above that GPI should consider."
* As Better in Our Back Yard's executive director, Ryan connects with public officials, business leaders and communities to share a positive, pro-industry message. Better in Our Back Yard advocates for federal permitting reform, critical minerals and domestic energy production to drive a more prosperous future for all.
31. Would you like to upload documents or other materials supporting your response?Please use the file upload option at the bottom of the form linked in the instructions above.
I recommend GPI download the PDF document in the following link: The Commonwealth of Australia's Handbook of Cost Benefit Analysis from January 2006.
I also recommend GPI download my two submissions to the Minnesota Public Utility Commission regarding their current energy affordability investigation:
* PUC energy affordability investigation: public comments due October 16
* PUC energy affordability investigation: public comments due November 6
32. Is there anything else GPI should consider when evaluating the potential impacts of new nuclear generation on the public interest in Minnesota?
Context matters. And when it comes to why the moratorium on new nuclear power should be lifted, context is crucial. Therefore:
* Wind and solar renewables are still, as of 2024, vastly more costly than nuclear, coal or natural gas reliables (see Chart 1 below).
* Wind has been the dominant renewable in MN in the 21st century, especially since 2004, with solar a distant second even in the 2020s (see Chart 2 below).
* MN renewables went from an afterthought, prior to the 21st century, to the top generation source nowadays, along with natural gas not far behind (see Chart 3 below).
* The growth of MN renewables in the 21st century has far outpaced that of the rest of the midwest (MW) region and the country (US) as a whole (see Chart 4 below).
* Twin Cities (MSP) electricity CPI inflation has thus, also far outpaced that of the MW and US in the 21st century (see Chart 5 below).
* MSP electricity CPI inflation has outpaced MSP general CPI inflation throughout the 21st century, as well as overtaking it in the 2010s and 2020s (see Chart 6 below).
* MN electricity rates have inflated by well over 100% in the 21st century for residential, commercial, industrial and total combined customer classes (see Chart 7 below).
* MN's state rankings on these four electricity rates have sunk throughout the 21st century, from almost top 10 for commercial in 2002, to almost bottom 10 for industrial 2022 (see Chart 8 below).
* These heavily inflating MN electricity rates have translated into skyrocketing electricity bills, on average for the three main customer classes combined (see Chart 9 below).
* MN electricity bills inflation is being driven up by increased rates and not by increased uses, noting { Bills = Revenues / Customers } and { Revenues = Rates x Uses } (see Chart 10 below).
* MN electricity uses peaked in 2008 and has sunk since, and given the Jevons paradox and Khazzoom-Brookes postulate, this strongly suggests not electricity cost efficiency but electricity price inflation (see Chart 11 below).
* This is very much reinforced by comparing MN electricity price inflation to MN natural gas price deflation between 2002 and 2025 (see Chart 12 below).
* This is also reinforced by comparing MN electricity revenues to MN natural gas revenues, the former of which are being pushed up by rates not uses, which in turn are being pushed up by renewables capex not equity returns (see Charts 13 and 14 below).
* * *
Darren Nelson is a Policy Fellow at Center of the American Experiment. darren.nelson@americanexperiment.org
* * *
Original text here: https://www.americanexperiment.org/mn-nuclear-energy-study-rfi-response-2/
[Category: ThinkTank]
Center of the American Experiment Issues Commentary: Factchecking the Factchecker
MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 15 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary:
* * *
Factchecking the factchecker
Written by Bill Glahn
November 13, 2026
State taxpayers are funding a ridiculous "fact check" website at the state Dept. of Human Services (DHS).
Truth before rhetoric ... The place for Minnesotans to find accurate information about our fight against fraud.
A bit of "accurate information" I'd like to find on this site is "how much fraud has there been"? Is it $9 billion? ... Show Full Article MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 15 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary: * * * Factchecking the factchecker Written by Bill Glahn November 13, 2026 State taxpayers are funding a ridiculous "fact check" website at the state Dept. of Human Services (DHS). Truth before rhetoric ... The place for Minnesotans to find accurate information about our fight against fraud. A bit of "accurate information" I'd like to find on this site is "how much fraud has there been"? Is it $9 billion?Some other number? I search in vain.
Instead, the "factchecking" toggles between "what fraud?" and "DHS is the only entity fighting the fraud" should any exist.
It's difficult to comprehend that the DHS factcheck content is written by adults and not DFL interns. Presumably, the site is authored by actual state government employees and union members.
As sample:
"In Minnesota they think [fraud is] $19 billion...triple it, quadruple it!"
DHS answer:
Speculation is not fraud. Our investigations continue and the situation is fluid. For this reason, there is no final number at this time.
Ok, then. How about a preliminary number? An interim number? An estimate?
The oldest entry dates from February 2026 and the latest (and presumably final entry) dates to November 2, the day before the election.
It has outlived its usefulness.
* * *
Bill Glahn is a Policy Fellow with Center of the American Experiment.
* * *
Original text here: https://www.americanexperiment.org/factchecking-the-factchecker/
[Category: ThinkTank]
* * *
Factchecking the factchecker
Written by Bill Glahn
November 13, 2026
State taxpayers are funding a ridiculous "fact check" website at the state Dept. of Human Services (DHS).
Truth before rhetoric ... The place for Minnesotans to find accurate information about our fight against fraud.
A bit of "accurate information" I'd like to find on this site is "how much fraud has there been"? Is it $9 billion? ... Show Full Article MINNETONKA, Minnesota, Nov. 15 -- The Center of the American Experiment, a civic and educational organization that says it creates and advocates policies, issued the following commentary: * * * Factchecking the factchecker Written by Bill Glahn November 13, 2026 State taxpayers are funding a ridiculous "fact check" website at the state Dept. of Human Services (DHS). Truth before rhetoric ... The place for Minnesotans to find accurate information about our fight against fraud. A bit of "accurate information" I'd like to find on this site is "how much fraud has there been"? Is it $9 billion?Some other number? I search in vain.
Instead, the "factchecking" toggles between "what fraud?" and "DHS is the only entity fighting the fraud" should any exist.
It's difficult to comprehend that the DHS factcheck content is written by adults and not DFL interns. Presumably, the site is authored by actual state government employees and union members.
As sample:
"In Minnesota they think [fraud is] $19 billion...triple it, quadruple it!"
DHS answer:
Speculation is not fraud. Our investigations continue and the situation is fluid. For this reason, there is no final number at this time.
Ok, then. How about a preliminary number? An interim number? An estimate?
The oldest entry dates from February 2026 and the latest (and presumably final entry) dates to November 2, the day before the election.
It has outlived its usefulness.
* * *
Bill Glahn is a Policy Fellow with Center of the American Experiment.
* * *
Original text here: https://www.americanexperiment.org/factchecking-the-factchecker/
[Category: ThinkTank]
